willemtway
Well-Known Member
Be interesting to note from Marks posting of today’s written press, to see if they are as sycophantic, though shall not criticise the NT as the Beeb were.
vomit inducing
vomit inducing
Mcleish would have been hounded and ridiculed for that team selectionBe interesting to note from Marks posting of today’s written press, to see if they are as sycophantic, though shall not criticise the NT as the Beeb were.
vomit inducing
Exactly mate.
The whole set up continues to be an absolute shambles.
Darren Fletcher was an absolute embarrassment post match. Total loser mentality. I bet SAF was cringing listening to him.I could have told you that game was going to happen as soon as they qualified.
Scotland have fully embraced the diddy team mindset of being 'just happy to be there'. About a decade ago, Roy Keane absolutely slaughtered ROI fans and coaches for having that mentality. You won't hear such dissenting voices in the Scottish media, instead you have Darren Fletcher giving it the happy clappy pish post-match and them talking about how great the atmosphere was when the game started.
Ryan Christie was always going to start despite turning in a season that shouldn't have even seen him included in the squad. David Marshall was always going to start in goal despite being dropped by a Derby team who were on the verge of being relegated from the English Championship. This is allowed to pass without much scrutiny or criticism.
Clarke basically gets a free pass from the media because he won a few penalty shoot outs that another coach put him in the position for. No one asks why a manager is entering a tournament without even roughly knowing his best starting eleven. No one asks why we're the only country that seems to see lumping it up to the big guy up front and picking a genuinely dreadful footballer at right back so he can challenge for long diagonals as legitimate offensive tactics in 2021.
It's utter pish and being a wee country isn't the excuse for it.
Darren Fletcher was an absolute embarrassment post match. Total loser mentality. I bet SAF was cringing listening to him.
Excellent post.I could have told you that game was going to happen as soon as they qualified.
Scotland have fully embraced the diddy team mindset of being 'just happy to be there'. About a decade ago, Roy Keane absolutely slaughtered ROI fans and coaches for having that mentality. You won't hear such dissenting voices in the Scottish media, instead you have Darren Fletcher giving it the happy clappy pish post-match and them talking about how great the atmosphere was when the game started.
Ryan Christie was always going to start despite turning in a season that shouldn't have even seen him included in the squad. David Marshall was always going to start in goal despite being dropped by a Derby team who were on the verge of being relegated from the English Championship. This is allowed to pass without much scrutiny or criticism.
Clarke basically gets a free pass from the media because he won a few penalty shoot outs that another coach put him in the position for. No one asks why a manager is entering a tournament without even roughly knowing his best starting eleven. No one asks why we're the only country that seems to see lumping it up to the big guy up front and picking a genuinely dreadful footballer at right back so he can challenge for long diagonals as legitimate offensive tactics in 2021.
It's utter pish and being a wee country isn't the excuse for it.
Nathan will make that position his own for years to come, but for this tournament surely even the boy Liam Palmer from Wednesday would have been a better player for the squad than O'Donnell, surely, he must be, he cannot be any worseThat idiot Clarke needs sacked after this Tournament, playing O'Donnell is one thing but the first three times he was neear the ball he back heeled one out of play, ran into Christie stopping his momentum, and crossed the ball 3 inches off the ground, absolutely pathetic!!!!!!!
He should have pulled him at half time. Don't get me started on subbing McGregor in. I knew Clarke would never play Gilmour or Patterson. What a major emabarressment. The second goal was a disastrous mistake too. It was like watching the keystone cops.
I agree completely and until that type of mindset is gone then they will never move forward.I could have told you that game was going to happen as soon as they qualified.
Scotland have fully embraced the diddy team mindset of being 'just happy to be there'. About a decade ago, Roy Keane absolutely slaughtered ROI fans and coaches for having that mentality. You won't hear such dissenting voices in the Scottish media, instead you have Darren Fletcher giving it the happy clappy pish post-match and them talking about how great the atmosphere was when the game started.
Ryan Christie was always going to start despite turning in a season that shouldn't have even seen him included in the squad. David Marshall was always going to start in goal despite being dropped by a Derby team who were on the verge of being relegated from the English Championship. This is allowed to pass without much scrutiny or criticism.
Clarke basically gets a free pass from the media because he won a few penalty shoot outs that another coach put him in the position for. No one asks why a manager is entering a tournament without even roughly knowing his best starting eleven. No one asks why we're the only country that seems to see lumping it up to the big guy up front and picking a genuinely dreadful footballer at right back so he can challenge for long diagonals as legitimate offensive tactics in 2021.
It's utter pish and being a wee country isn't the excuse for it.
He’s a fudDarren Fletcher was an absolute embarrassment post match. Total loser mentality. I bet SAF was cringing listening to him.
Yip. By a number of his team mates even before SAF got a hold of him.It was completely disingenuous. Comparing the start to Portugal's in 2016.
Can you imagine him getting away with that turd polishing in a dressing room under SAF? Would have been told to sit down and fück up in five seconds flat.
Exactly. Going with the same tired old failures time after time and expecting things to be different. The game in this country has needed root and branch change for what seems like my entire life. Why can't we produce technically gifted, tactically aware footballers? Watching O'Donnell yesterday was genuinely painful. He'd be a Sunday league player down south.Scotland need to hire a young, tactically innovative coaching team and give them 8-10 years to build up all the national teams from U17s up. They would probably have to hire from outside the country and I would look to Germany or Portugal as they are producing a lot of good young managers right now.
The O'Donnell thing is purely on Clarke.Exactly. Going with the same tired old failures time after time and expecting things to be different. The game in this country has needed root and branch change for what seems like my entire life. Why can't we produce technically gifted, tactically aware footballers? Watching O'Donnell yesterday was genuinely painful. He'd be a Sunday league player down south.
Where are they though? We play in a league where most of the teams are willing to give jobs to no marks from the league of Ireland because they must be the cheap option.Scotland need to hire a young, tactically innovative coaching team and give them 8-10 years to build up all the national teams from U17s up. They would probably have to hire from outside the country and I would look to Germany or Portugal as they are producing a lot of good young managers right now.
Thats why we need to go foreign even if that is only as far as England although Germany would be my choice. The overhaul needs someone from the outside with no previous notions about Scottish football and an unbiased view.Where are they though? We play in a league where most of the teams are willing to give jobs to no marks from the league of Ireland because they must be the cheap option.
After Clarke it will no doubt be McInnes. Another clown who probably wouldn’t have set up much differently than yesterday.
I’m not a fan of countries having foreign coaches. It should be your country against the other including coaches imo.Thats why we need to go foreign even if that is only as far as England although Germany would be my choice. The overhaul needs someone from the outside with no previous notions about Scottish football and an unbiased view.
I’m not a fan of countries having foreign coaches. It should be your country against the other including coaches imo.
I did however say to my old man last night only a Scottish manager doesn’t play the most technically gifted midfielder available and instead play three guys who run around a lot.
I took England-1 last night. I think they will beat us by as many as the want to.How do you think we will line up against England then?
I bet the ONLY changes will be Adams for Christie, and Cooper for Tierney you just know it.
Nisbett was crap too - if Wykes and him are what Celtic are looking at next season then I’m rubbing my hands. He may go on to be a good player in a few years but on yesterday’s showing he is miles away from elite level.Nisbet was more of a threat in the 10 minutes he had than Dykes.
If ever a game shows that XG is a lot of shite that’s it
I like my stats, and in the main I do think these paint a picture that Scotland did have the better chances.
The flip side to that is there is no context here, these stats don’t tell you just how bad Scotland played.
I would generally agree, but who was the last good Scottish coach? If we stick with Scots only our next 3 managers will be, in order, McInnes, Ross and then Davidson.I’m not a fan of countries having foreign coaches. It should be your country against the other including coaches imo.
I did however say to my old man last night only a Scottish manager doesn’t play the most technically gifted midfielder available and instead play three guys who run around a lot.
If you moulded all their best assets into one player they would still be half the player Barry Ferguson was.There isn't a single scrap of technical ability in McTominay, McGinn or Armstrong mate.
All about perspiration and fuuck all inspiration.
I agree. We should just withdraw completelyI would generally agree, but who was the last good Scottish coach? If we stick with Scots only our next 3 managers will be, in order, McInnes, Ross and then Davidson.
i believe it's a 'gentlemen's agreement'.I don't think there was such a chance. As far as I know, it isn't allowed under the agreement between the UK FAs, which has been ratified by FIFA,
This was a very poor result which has quite possibly put paid to our chances of qualifying from the group.
From a Czech point of view the goals were superb. From our perspective, questions have to be asked about our defenders and goalkeeper.
i believe it's a 'gentlemen's agreement'.
McGregor and Forrest will be the first names on the team sheet.How do you think we will line up against England then?
I bet the ONLY changes will be Adams for Christie, and Cooper for Tierney you just know it.
Which I’m glad, the residency rule is ridiculous IMO.Like I said, I believe it has been ratified by FIFA.
I don’t understand why coaches don’t go into school and teach football? At school we got basketball, volleyball and gymnasticsThe only country in the world who could bring in a guy who revolutionised Dutch football (Rinus Michels), ask him to evaluate and recommend changes to improve Scottish football ….. and completely ignore said recommendations, probably because it would have involved effort, spending money and some back bone to see them through.
I’ve watched smaller countries than ours, closer to home (Wales and NI) who hadn’t qualified for a major tournament in an even longer time than Scotland, go out and give it their all, not just content to “be there in the first place”, as seems to be the mindset here.
I like my stats too so thanks for posting.
I like my stats, and in the main I do think these paint a picture that Scotland did have the better chances.
The flip side to that is there is no context here, these stats don’t tell you just how bad Scotland played.
We got football in school to be fair.I don’t understand why coaches don’t go into school and teach football? At school we got basketball, volleyball and gymnastics
Why are they not teaching the sport that is the national game in schools? Surely the SFA could come up with a programme that would see decent level coaches going into schools and teaching kids how to play football?
Taught by a teacher or someone who actually knew what they were talking about?We got football in school to be fair.
PE was blocks of different sports and football was one, had a theory class (going over basic tactics, overlapping full backs and the like) along with a practical class.
Most of it would be basic tactical stuff, but some days we would just play games of 7s or 11s which became pish because nobody could be bothered.
Argument could be made that any actual coaches that were hired would know less than the regular teachersTaught by a teacher or someone who actually knew what they were talking about?
My PE teacher was a Rangers coach. And we played football constantly. This was 97-03.Taught by a teacher or someone who actually knew what they were talking about?
Think they were teachers that had coaching badges, the issue with getting proper coaches in like you suggested is there would be outcry from pupils that played badminton or hockey if they didn’t get coaches too!.Taught by a teacher or someone who actually knew what they were talking about?
I’d be curious to see where ours is coming from, I presume the two Dykes chances and the Robertson one (I think the Robertson one wasn’t easy).I like my stats too so thanks for posting.
I also wonder how many of the xG were added when we were 2-0 down and they were happy to concede possession to us.
The xG fuels the 'we were unlucky' narrative. The question for me is how much is our lack of goals down to poor luck or poor quality
I’d be curious to see where ours is coming from, I presume the two Dykes chances and the Robertson one (I think the Robertson one wasn’t easy).
Wonder if there’s a breakdown anywhere.
Robertson, is classed as a very good player down at his club, its the great players when they get that one chance and they take it, robbos shot is going over even before the keeper touches it, he seems incapable of keeping his shots down, that's the difference.I’d be curious to see where ours is coming from, I presume the two Dykes chances and the Robertson one (I think the Robertson one wasn’t easy).
Wonder if there’s a breakdown anywhere.
Forrest is not physically equipped to play that role against England.I think Clarke will go with the following team for the England game:
Marshall
Hanley Cooper Hendry
Forrest McTominay McGinn McGregor Robertson
Adams Nisbet
Personally I'd have Gilmour in ahead of McGregor.
Forrest actually did well when he came on and offered a lot more than O'Donnell but that wouldn't have been hard.
What racism?
Robertson, is classed as a very good player down at his club, its the great players when they get that one chance and they take it, robbos shot is going over even before the keeper touches it, he seems incapable of keeping his shots down, that's the difference.