I suppose what you do in other leagues doesn't mean you cant do better here but i would like someone who can score more than 9 goals in his best season in that position. He's a good player but i question if he can bring those extra goals that we need out of that positionNo10
I watch Hamburg every week and have done before Holtby signed. Hes inconsistent and isn't the player he could've been when he first showed signs of being a decent playerHow many people actually watch Hamburg regularly enough to judge how good he'd be?
Comments already from folk saying he'd be class & others saying he'd be grim. Doubt anyone's saw him enough to be able to form such strong opinions on the lad.
The fact that he's started nearly every game for them this season & captained them on occasion is encouraging enough for me.
Our league is full of thugsBased on what? He is one of their most hard working players, guy never stops running
do you think there is interest from our side?
He looks like the T-1000. That'll do for me.
change into messi lol
Hopefully he can run like him too. Also stick that extended arm blade thing of his in any opponent that comes near him
Took 27 posts to find the drama queen.Oh my god please no.
It’s only my opinion & on what I’ve seen from him, not assuming anything tbf
He’s extremely inconsistent & seems to only turn it on when interested
Few years ago absolutely
Now I wouldn’t
If I am wrong & he is good then why are Hamburg releasing him?
Haven't heard of him. Has he fallen out of favour at HSV?
You may not have seen him play recently but you have heard of him
I genuinely haven't.
5 goals and 6 assists in the second tier this season.
Think we need better.
Lewis holtby player for spurs , Fulham and German international , you have mate
Have you seen him play recently?certainly came out of the blue. Hopefully true, being linked with a player of that calibre is encouraging and an upgrade on the midfielders we have
Have you seen him play recently?
So he's both very good and shite?
The son of Chris Holtby, a former British soldier who was stationed at RAF Rheindahlen in Monchengladbach he was eligible to represent England through paternal lineage as well as his native Germany.Is he half English? not many Germans called Lewis surely?
It’s only my opinion & on what I’ve seen from him, not assuming anything tbf
He’s extremely inconsistent & seems to only turn it on when interested
Few years ago absolutely
Now I wouldn’t
If I am wrong & he is good then why are Hamburg releasing him?
Don’t think he’s that much better than arfield to be honest, who should be a squad player next season. People seem to be getting excited by the name here, he’s not the game changer we need to compete for the titleIn the games I've seen on bt this season he's done just fine.
Irrespective of whether he’s good or shit, why would he come to Scotland?
It won’t have escaped him surely that the games a bogey here.
It’s only my opinion & on what I’ve seen from him, not assuming anything tbf
He’s extremely inconsistent & seems to only turn it on when interested
Few years ago absolutely
Now I wouldn’t
If I am wrong & he is good then why are Hamburg releasing him?
He couldnt lace big Jorg's boots mateAn inconsistent German midfielder with a decent left peg???
Reminds me of someone, yes please!!
While that might be true Murphy (despite being Irish and a pape) is usually bulletproof when it comes to German football.Would love for him to be a target but the journalist works for goal.com.
They're generally not that reliable.
An inconsistent German midfielder with a decent left peg???
Reminds me of someone, yes please!!