Lowland league

Had a look at the Lowland league table-18 teams-Albion Rovers,Berwick Rangers,Cowdenbeath and East Stirlingshire are all in the bottom 6. Just shows that these teams were kept in the SPFL too long and a full pyramid system with B teams is the way to go as Rangers suggested.

Not quite sure how any of this means B Teams should be included.
 
B teams have been voted in for another 2 seasons. Apparently we are considering it. We should absolutely play again in the LL. Our B team has suffered without regular competitive football

No it hasn't. The B team in the lowland league hasn't prepared players for a team who plays in a league 4 divisions above. It's a silly idea that hasn't proved fruitful in the slightest.

If we could get further up, maybe, but the lowland league is rubbish.
 
No it hasn't. The B team in the lowland league hasn't prepared players for a team who plays in a league 4 divisions above. It's a silly idea that hasn't proved fruitful in the slightest.

If we could get further up, maybe, but the lowland league is rubbish.
Why didnt any of the B teams top the league then?
 
Why didnt any of the B teams top the league then?

Because the majority of the B players are nowhere near good enough for Rangers and round about that level is where they will find themselves (between league 1 and the lowland league). You're talking about preparing players for playing for Rangers whilst they play every week against guys who they used to play against when younger but who fell out the pro youth system. The lowland league is filled with guys who fell out pro youth at ages 12-16.

Believe me mate, the west of scotland premier division is probably pound for pound a better league. The lowland league is quite artificial.

I've either played with or coached quite a few guys who have played or who play lowland league. It's a poor standard in relation to the Premiership. No use.
 
No it hasn't. The B team in the lowland league hasn't prepared players for a team who plays in a league 4 divisions above. It's a silly idea that hasn't proved fruitful in the slightest.

If we could get further up, maybe, but the lowland league is rubbish.
It is certainly better than playing next to no competitive football this season
 
No it hasn't. The B team in the lowland league hasn't prepared players for a team who plays in a league 4 divisions above. It's a silly idea that hasn't proved fruitful in the slightest.

If we could get further up, maybe, but the lowland league is rubbish.

Who have our B Team been playing against since they left the Lowland League?

Yes, and I'll confirm again, B Teams should be nowhere near the pyramid.

So do Spain, Portugal, Holland etc all have it wrong?
 
B teams have been voted in for another 2 seasons. Apparently we are considering it. We should absolutely play again in the LL. Our B team has suffered without regular competitive football

8-7 without 1 club voting. Saw Albion Rovers kick up a fuss about it and good old sporting integrity making a comeback.
 
Yes, and I'll confirm again, B Teams should be nowhere near the pyramid.
Fair enough, thats your opinion. I misunderstood and thought you didnt want the B team in the lowland league. But you actually don't want them involved in any of the Scottish league?

Odd take imo. All the top leagues have their under 21s playing in competitive mens leagues and are better for it, as Clement himself was saying at the recent press conference.
 
No it hasn't. The B team in the lowland league hasn't prepared players for a team who plays in a league 4 divisions above. It's a silly idea that hasn't proved fruitful in the slightest.

If we could get further up, maybe, but the lowland league is rubbish.

It's managed to get Lowry, King, Devine all on the fringes of the first time and also Ross McAusland as well. It's good for them in terms of learning the demands of 3 games a week how to prepare for matches on and off the pitch etc.
 
It's managed to get Lowry, King, Devine all on the fringes of the first time and also Ross McAusland as well. It's good for them in terms of learning the demands of 3 games a week how to prepare for matches on and off the pitch etc.

Not really. We've always had some youths who float about the fringes of the first team and the odd one break in. Nothing unusual has happened.

I'd flip that and say if these guys hadn't spent important years playing at a level below them then they may actually have properly broke in to our team.

King, as an example, went from.playing in the 5th tier of Scottish football which is beneath him hugely to playing against Mo Salah and Bobby Firmino in a matter of weeks. It's nowhere near the level we need to test our best youths at.
 
Not really. We've always had some youths who float about the fringes of the first team and the odd one break in. Nothing unusual has happened.

I'd flip that and say if these guys hadn't spent important years playing at a level below them then they may actually have properly broke in to our team.

King, as an example, went from.playing in the 5th tier of Scottish football which is beneath him hugely to playing against Mo Salah and Bobby Firmino in a matter of weeks. It's nowhere near the level we need to test our best youths at.

McCausland is the perfect example of it working he couldn't get a deal with De Graafschap after going on trial there. Came back had another year at Lowland level playing 40 plus games and is now starting games for the first team.

There's never going to be a setup at any level in Scotland that prepares you to play against world class players like Salah. King should have been out on loan this season to get more game time but there's no way the current setup is working either.
 
McCausland is the perfect example of it working he couldn't get a deal with De Graafschap after going on trial there. Came back had another year at Lowland level playing 40 plus games and is now starting games for the first team.

There's never going to be a setup at any level in Scotland that prepares you to play against world class players like Salah. King should have been out on loan this season to get more game time but there's no way the current setup is working either.

McAusland getting into the team isn't because he played Lowland League mate. As I've said above, much of the league is made up of guys who were let go from pro youth at various points. If they are good enough for Rangers, the Lowland league is miles below that.

We need our best youths, as an absolute minimum, on loan in the Premiership and, preferably, on loan in a top (ie first league) league abroad.

Not messing around playijg against guys deemed not good enough for their level already.

The Reserve League should be brought back in the short term imo. Guys getting to play against experienced players who play at the level they aspire to be at.

Have to add mate that you're well entitled to your opinion.

I just think, in fact I know, that the level is miles below where we need to be testing our youths and, as such, actually sees them stagnate a bit.
 
McAusland getting into the team isn't because he played Lowland League mate. As I've said above, much of the league is made up of guys who were let go from pro youth at various points. If they are good enough for Rangers, the Lowland league is miles below that.

We need our best youths, as an absolute minimum, on loan in the Premiership and, preferably, on loan in a top (ie first league) league abroad.

Not messing around playijg against guys deemed not good enough for their level already.

The Reserve League should be brought back in the short term imo. Guys getting to play against experienced players who play at the level they aspire to be at.

Have to add mate that you're well entitled to your opinion.

I just think, in fact I know, that the level is miles below where we need to be testing our youths and, as such, actually sees them stagnate a bit.
Some fair points.

Rangers didn't even enter a side in the reserve league this year which I found quite strange but I know that league has had it's problems to. These players aren't going to improve playing 1-2 games a month though.
 
McAusland getting into the team isn't because he played Lowland League mate. As I've said above, much of the league is made up of guys who were let go from pro youth at various points. If they are good enough for Rangers, the Lowland league is miles below that.

We need our best youths, as an absolute minimum, on loan in the Premiership and, preferably, on loan in a top league abroad.

Not messing around playijg against guys deemed not good enough for their level already.

The Reserve League should be brought back in the short term imo. Guys getting to play against experienced players who play at the level they aspire to be at.

Well what is it for McCausland then? You don't think playing over 40 games at B team level has done anything for his development?

That's never going to happen with our loans for youth players because half of them aren't good enough to play in the SPFL top flight never mind abroad. There's a reserve league there but the opposite has happened of what you mention and we ended up playing against the same players they've grown up against so we pulled out as did the tims.

The Lowland is a crap level but it's the only level that's willing to help with youth development. Kids playing 50-60 games a season will do far more for their development than what is happening this season.
 
Well what is it for McCausland then? You don't think playing over 40 games at B team level has done anything for his development?

That's never going to happen with our loans for youth players because half of them aren't good enough to play in the SPFL top flight never mind abroad. There's a reserve league there but the opposite has happened of what you mention and we ended up playing against the same players they've grown up against so we pulled out as did the tims.

The Lowland is a crap level but it's the only level that's willing to help with youth development. Kids playing 50-60 games a season will do far more for their development than what is happening this season.

I feel the time in the Lowland League stagnated our youths. They've played loads of football games in their life. It's getting challenge that counts and the guys in thr lowland league are no challenge. McAusland would have benefitted more from a good loan. Invariably though, he has been lucky to have come into contact with Clement.

If I could give you an example. I coached, for a short time, a player who was one of the absolute jewels in Celtics youth system when he was younger. He was a Rangers fan and they moved heaven and earth to take him from us.

He was an incredible talent but over the years eventually got released and ended up in the lowland league last year where he did well and now plays in League 2 where he is again doing well. That isn't a challenge for guys who made it all the way through the Rangers youth system to play against these guys.

I know, and have coached, a number of League 1, 2 and Lowland League players so I know their backgrounds and, though good players, they all tend to come from a level which is way below those who have went all the way through the Rangers youth system like McAusland.
 
Fair enough, thats your opinion. I misunderstood and thought you didnt want the B team in the lowland league. But you actually don't want them involved in any of the Scottish league?

Odd take imo. All the top leagues have their under 21s playing in competitive mens leagues and are better for it, as Clement himself was saying at the recent press conference.

Not really an odd take. There has been zero/little benefit from the Lowland league and the standard of player below a few clubs in the championship is rotten. It needs (like other top leagues) full time football and competition, and not bit part-part timers.

Until such time that changes, we're as well having them train FT with our own players and continue playing competitive friendlies.
 
I think something needs to change with it. I can understand why there’s not an appetite in Scotland for it though.

The leagues are already pretty diluted with clubs for a nation our size and games like Dunfermline/Arbroath/Dundee United vs Rangers B just isn’t attractive to fans of those clubs.

The culture here doesn’t really support it, fans want Saturday at 3pm whereas the Eerste Divisie works well with its 7pm Friday and Monday games because it feels more independent from the top league. You can’t expect part time clubs to move to that schedule full time though.

The lowland league just isn’t a good enough standard for development.

IMO we need a league independent to our own, if joining the Premier League 2 was an option then we should consider that they also have the Premier League international cup for academies in Europe that Celtic are part of this season.

If we went with our own I’d propose:

Independent League
5 players over 21 allowed
Summer season invite academies from Scotland, Ireland, Wales, Norway, Finland and Sweden.
 
Scottish football is stale and has been for a number of years. We've already played Hearts, Aberdeen and Livingston 3 times this season and there are still 5 months to go and we could play Hearts another 3 times.

It needs bigger leagues, more movement between the leagues and I don't see the problem with at least trying out having B-Teams from Tier 2 and below like most other countries have.

One of the biggest issues is the number of organisations running single leagues which all look after themselves. Lowland League reluctant to open up places to East/West for example.

Really wish there was a stronger leadership that could do something about it. Dunno what power the SFA have over this as governing body but these leagues must need some sort of permission from the governing body to run competitions so there should be a set criteria for promotion and relegation so these leagues can't hide behind playoffs to bottleneck better teams trying to move up the pyramid.
 
Some fair points.

Rangers didn't even enter a side in the reserve league this year which I found quite strange but I know that league has had it's problems to. These players aren't going to improve playing 1-2 games a month though.
I think we only ever did it as we had hopes they'd eventually be allowed to be promoted. It was clear we were never going to be allowed to be promoted and they were wanting us to pay a decent sum just to be in the Lowland league where some thug gave Lowry a serious injury the season before.
 
Our top league in this country has 2 clubs at the top with 50 thousand plus crowds and we have a Livingston who are lucky if they have a 1,000 fans, although they have earned the right to be in it.

The imbalance on scottish football can never be repaired now. Too many heading to Glasgow from all over the country and with the way money is now king in football, there's no way back.
 
IIRC Mulholland said there would be an “elite”level programme playing against bigger club youth teams which he/the club thought would be better for their development than the LL.

Recently I think we’ve played Man Utd & Brighton possibly? Sounds fine, but I dare say the games would have a “friendly’ feel to them - seems it’s that or the LL at the end of the day…
 
Lowland League is a plastic invention. Sadly No one in Leagues One or Two will open up the Pyramid as half of them know what's coming.

Look at the teams dropping out, many dead or dying Clubs with circa 300 attendances hanging on. The don't want an open competition, they don't want a fair field and would rather hang on to the League and SFA purse strings as a life support. The current set up crushes growth, ambition and variety of competition. Serves up the same games, same teams and hinders development. You need bigger divisions at the top and regional football to be put in place below League 1.
 
Who have our B Team been playing against since they left the Lowland League?



So do Spain, Portugal, Holland etc all have it wrong?

Jong Ajax are playing against a better standard of team than Gretna 2008. Gretna having a goal difference of -61.

B team football can work. But it's not B team football itself that's the success factor. It's the standard of coaching from a young age. It's keeping the youngsters focused on their football. It's the standard of opposition. It's having a clear pathway to first team football.

Nobody champions the involvement of 2nd teams in German football. Probably because they tend not to do particularly well, because 3.liga fans tend to hate games against 2nd teams and because there's more of a culture of sending young players out on loan.

B teams is seen by too many as a magic wand. By and large by many of the same fans who will go on to complain about how shite Scottish football is and how little lower league club sides add to the game. Can't have it both ways folks - why would you want the best young talent to be playing against the likes of Gretna, Clyde and Annan Athletic if you all think that lower league Scottish football is so poor?
 
I think we only ever did it as we had hopes they'd eventually be allowed to be promoted. It was clear we were never going to be allowed to be promoted and they were wanting us to pay a decent sum just to be in the Lowland league where some thug gave Lowry a serious injury the season before.
That was a cup game not lowland league game
 
That was a cup game not lowland league game
Fair play, you're right, I've got that mixed up.

But think my basic point is correct, we saw it as a way to get the foot in the door to get b teams accepted in the league set up proper. When it was clear that was never going to be allowed we decided it wasn't worth paying for the privilege to have our players plating at such a low level
 
No sign of the LL fixtures being announced yet? Already a week on from last year’s announcement.

I need to know if I’m heading to Berwick after Birmingham.
 

Getting to Know – Broxburn Athletic​

Jul 5, 2024

by
Matt Cooke
in ‘Getting to Know’
Getting to Know – Broxburn Athletic
Broxburn-Athletic.png


Prior to last season, we ran a really popular series of ‘Getting to Know’ taking a closer look at several of our lesser known non league clubs. So, we thought why not bring this back for a Series Two, and we started off last week with a look at Bourne Town (article can be found here). This week though we’re excited to be taking our first ever trip to Scotland, and Broxburn Athletic, a club I’ve really enjoyed getting to know, and I’m sure you will too.

Formed in 1947, as you can see from their excellent club badge, which also bares the emblem of their nickname ‘The Badgers’, Broxburn are based in West Lothian, at their home ground of Albyn Park. I subsequently discovered that the name Broxburn is taken from the Gaelic work ‘Brock’, which means Badger. They have enjoyed very recent success in winning the East of Scotland Premier League and this season take their rightful place in the Scottish Lowland League, step five of the Scottish football pyramid. Let’s see what else we find out….

Broxburn-Atletic-Celebrate-1024x672.jpg
Broxburn Athletic players and supports celebrate after gaining promotion to the Scottish Lowland League.

Firstly, congratulations on your recent success, not only winning the East of Scotland Premier Division title, but then your convincing playoff win over Dalbeattie Star to gain promotion to the Scottish Lowland League. Please sum up your thoughts on how the season went and what this means to the club and the local community to make this step up the Scottish football pyramid?

“It was great campaign both on and off the park, we came into the campaign knowing that significant improvement was needed from the season before when we finished in 9th place and it was clear from the first match (and pre-season) that it was a different campaign ahead. For the club, the success is a huge step, there has been belief for a while that the Lowland League is one we can compete well in and we feel we’ve proven that with results we have had in various cup competitions over previous years. We started the campaign off in great form winning 10 of our first 11 matches, moving to the top of the table in early September and we never left that spot! We had good runs in cup competitions as well, albeit exiting them in tough situations, particularly the Scottish Cup and League Cup. For the community we take the turnouts we’ve seen this campaign as a positive reflection on how they’ve responded to us, over 300 on average and our largest home crowd of recent years for the Scottish Cup match against Buckie Thistle where the support was fantastic.”

Champions-1024x682.png
East of Scotland League champions, Broxburn Athletic.

For those who have not heard of Broxburn Athletic before, or know very little, please can you give us a brief history of the club? When and how they were formed, players that have gone on to greater things, or any club successes along the way.

“There have been a number of teams in Broxburn through the long history of the town, but Broxburn Athletic were re-formed post war in 1947, with Albyn Park as our base ever since. Playing in the East Region leagues of the Junior set-up then moving to the senior football pyramid in 2018. The 50s and 70s proved fruitful for the club in terms of honours with a number of league and cup wins but these have been rarer in recent years with East of Scotland Conference win and last seasons league win the main two recent successes but we’ve gone without a cup lift since ’88.”

Please can you tell us the biggest day-to-day challenges a club the size of Broxburn Athletic face?

“The logistics of matchday are probably our most challenging but we handle it well. In some ways we are a victim of our own successes, with very busy matchday hospitality on top of the various roles needed to operate the club on a Saturday afternoon meaning we rely on so many volunteers to give up their time for the club as we also bring in between 200 and 1,200 people through the gate like we did this season.”

So, next season is an exciting year, with Broxburn Athletic competing at tier 5 in Scotland, what are you and the club looking forward to the most for this upcoming year?

“A new league brings a lot of intrigue, there are a number of familiar teams in the Lowland League however there are also a number of new teams for us to face on a regular competitive basis and also the likes of Berwick Rangers, Cowdenbeath and Albion Rovers now having made the step down from the SPFL. New teams mean new grounds for our supporters to visit and also new people to host at the Albyn and we always look forward to that.”

What’s the aim for next season? Is it just to find your feet at this level and consolidate, or are you setting your sights higher?

“As Pitts said in a previous interview, we’re not here to make up the numbers this season, we’re in the league for a reason and we’re here to compete. The quality overall is obviously a step up from what we experienced last season but we’ve also proven that we can take on the teams in tier 5 and take away a result.”

How’s the squad looking? Have you managed to retain most from last season, or is it more of a new look squad?

“We’ve retained a really good number of players from last season, but there are definitely a few additions that we’ll make to strengthen the squad and give us the depth we need to compete in the Lowland League, we played periods of the season making-do in some positions that we’ll hopefully shore up in the close season.”

Please can you tell us a little of the ground that you play in? Are improvements needed due to the promotion?

“We don’t need any improvements in the Lowland League as we hold the appropriate licensing requirements but there are ideas in the pipeline. We’re fortunate that the facility was overhauled almost 15 years ago meaning we have a modern clubhouse with really good facilities that we can make the most of on matchdays. Next step will be a seated enclosure at the ground but it’s a significant financial move so it’s not a quick step.”

Ground-Aerial-1024x768.jpg
An aerial view of Albyn Park.

Please tell us more about your role within the club.

“I take on quite a few roles as is pretty common in clubs at this level. I joined the club as, and my main roles is, Club Chaplain appointed through Sports Chaplaincy Scotland. In addition to that role I help out in training sessions, help in various place on matchdays and run the clubs social media pages as well as creating content on matchdays alongside Robbie. A bit of everything!”

Andrew, I really appreciate your time to speak with us, as I know that this is a busy time of year for you. Best of luck in your Lowland League campaign and the season in general, we very much look forward to seeing how you get on.

So that’s our first foray into getting to know a Scottish non league club, hopefully the first of many. I must admit though, for me personally, I’ve really enjoyed learning some more about Broxburn Athletic as it seems like a wonderful club, and it’s a shame of the distance as I’d really like to visit. Hopefully one day soon I can make that happen.

Keep an eye out next week for our next instalment, as we’re off to Wales. Until then, thanks for reading….

#nonleague #nonleaguescotland #scottishfootball #broxburn #broxburnathletic #lowlandleague
 

Getting to Know – Broxburn Athletic​

Jul 5, 2024

by
Matt Cooke
in ‘Getting to Know’

Broxburn-Athletic.png


Prior to last season, we ran a really popular series of ‘Getting to Know’ taking a closer look at several of our lesser known non league clubs. So, we thought why not bring this back for a Series Two, and we started off last week with a look at Bourne Town (article can be found here). This week though we’re excited to be taking our first ever trip to Scotland, and Broxburn Athletic, a club I’ve really enjoyed getting to know, and I’m sure you will too.

Formed in 1947, as you can see from their excellent club badge, which also bares the emblem of their nickname ‘The Badgers’, Broxburn are based in West Lothian, at their home ground of Albyn Park. I subsequently discovered that the name Broxburn is taken from the Gaelic work ‘Brock’, which means Badger. They have enjoyed very recent success in winning the East of Scotland Premier League and this season take their rightful place in the Scottish Lowland League, step five of the Scottish football pyramid. Let’s see what else we find out….

Broxburn-Atletic-Celebrate-1024x672.jpg
Broxburn Athletic players and supports celebrate after gaining promotion to the Scottish Lowland League.

Firstly, congratulations on your recent success, not only winning the East of Scotland Premier Division title, but then your convincing playoff win over Dalbeattie Star to gain promotion to the Scottish Lowland League. Please sum up your thoughts on how the season went and what this means to the club and the local community to make this step up the Scottish football pyramid?

“It was great campaign both on and off the park, we came into the campaign knowing that significant improvement was needed from the season before when we finished in 9th place and it was clear from the first match (and pre-season) that it was a different campaign ahead. For the club, the success is a huge step, there has been belief for a while that the Lowland League is one we can compete well in and we feel we’ve proven that with results we have had in various cup competitions over previous years. We started the campaign off in great form winning 10 of our first 11 matches, moving to the top of the table in early September and we never left that spot! We had good runs in cup competitions as well, albeit exiting them in tough situations, particularly the Scottish Cup and League Cup. For the community we take the turnouts we’ve seen this campaign as a positive reflection on how they’ve responded to us, over 300 on average and our largest home crowd of recent years for the Scottish Cup match against Buckie Thistle where the support was fantastic.”

Champions-1024x682.png
East of Scotland League champions, Broxburn Athletic.

For those who have not heard of Broxburn Athletic before, or know very little, please can you give us a brief history of the club? When and how they were formed, players that have gone on to greater things, or any club successes along the way.

“There have been a number of teams in Broxburn through the long history of the town, but Broxburn Athletic were re-formed post war in 1947, with Albyn Park as our base ever since. Playing in the East Region leagues of the Junior set-up then moving to the senior football pyramid in 2018. The 50s and 70s proved fruitful for the club in terms of honours with a number of league and cup wins but these have been rarer in recent years with East of Scotland Conference win and last seasons league win the main two recent successes but we’ve gone without a cup lift since ’88.”

Please can you tell us the biggest day-to-day challenges a club the size of Broxburn Athletic face?

“The logistics of matchday are probably our most challenging but we handle it well. In some ways we are a victim of our own successes, with very busy matchday hospitality on top of the various roles needed to operate the club on a Saturday afternoon meaning we rely on so many volunteers to give up their time for the club as we also bring in between 200 and 1,200 people through the gate like we did this season.”

So, next season is an exciting year, with Broxburn Athletic competing at tier 5 in Scotland, what are you and the club looking forward to the most for this upcoming year?

“A new league brings a lot of intrigue, there are a number of familiar teams in the Lowland League however there are also a number of new teams for us to face on a regular competitive basis and also the likes of Berwick Rangers, Cowdenbeath and Albion Rovers now having made the step down from the SPFL. New teams mean new grounds for our supporters to visit and also new people to host at the Albyn and we always look forward to that.”

What’s the aim for next season? Is it just to find your feet at this level and consolidate, or are you setting your sights higher?

“As Pitts said in a previous interview, we’re not here to make up the numbers this season, we’re in the league for a reason and we’re here to compete. The quality overall is obviously a step up from what we experienced last season but we’ve also proven that we can take on the teams in tier 5 and take away a result.”

How’s the squad looking? Have you managed to retain most from last season, or is it more of a new look squad?

“We’ve retained a really good number of players from last season, but there are definitely a few additions that we’ll make to strengthen the squad and give us the depth we need to compete in the Lowland League, we played periods of the season making-do in some positions that we’ll hopefully shore up in the close season.”

Please can you tell us a little of the ground that you play in? Are improvements needed due to the promotion?

“We don’t need any improvements in the Lowland League as we hold the appropriate licensing requirements but there are ideas in the pipeline. We’re fortunate that the facility was overhauled almost 15 years ago meaning we have a modern clubhouse with really good facilities that we can make the most of on matchdays. Next step will be a seated enclosure at the ground but it’s a significant financial move so it’s not a quick step.”

Ground-Aerial-1024x768.jpg
An aerial view of Albyn Park.

Please tell us more about your role within the club.

“I take on quite a few roles as is pretty common in clubs at this level. I joined the club as, and my main roles is, Club Chaplain appointed through Sports Chaplaincy Scotland. In addition to that role I help out in training sessions, help in various place on matchdays and run the clubs social media pages as well as creating content on matchdays alongside Robbie. A bit of everything!”

Andrew, I really appreciate your time to speak with us, as I know that this is a busy time of year for you. Best of luck in your Lowland League campaign and the season in general, we very much look forward to seeing how you get on.

So that’s our first foray into getting to know a Scottish non league club, hopefully the first of many. I must admit though, for me personally, I’ve really enjoyed learning some more about Broxburn Athletic as it seems like a wonderful club, and it’s a shame of the distance as I’d really like to visit. Hopefully one day soon I can make that happen.

Keep an eye out next week for our next instalment, as we’re off to Wales. Until then, thanks for reading….

#nonleague #nonleaguescotland #scottishfootball #broxburn #broxburnathletic #lowlandleague
A well run club and a really good set up there. Definitely deserve their spot in the LL. Had a few unsavoury incidents with fans towards the end of least season but those appear to be isolated incidents (I know there was the incident the other night too but that seems to have been Edinburgh City fans).
 
Had a look at the Lowland league table-18 teams-Albion Rovers,Berwick Rangers,Cowdenbeath and East Stirlingshire are all in the bottom 6. Just shows that these teams were kept in the SPFL too long and a full pyramid system with B teams is the way to go as Rangers suggested.
I agree with your argument for greater movement between the leagues, but not for B teams. The lower leagues have a purpose in themselves; they're not just there as finishing schools for Rangers and Celtic youth.
 
Why did the SFA ever do away with the reserve league? It was good to get injured players back to fitness and playing competitively

I know Celtic and hearts b teams play in the lowland league but where does Aberdeen Dundee b teams play?
 
For all the fury about not allowing B Teams to progress through the leagues, Its up to those B Teams to start winning the League each season to strengthen the argument

Nobody has won it yet so maybe it's actually not a bad level at all

I think Rangers made a big mistake pulling out of it

The idea was always to test physicality against men rather than fellow youths and experience uncomfortable environments which dont happen playing at youth level
 
Had a look at the Lowland league table-18 teams-Albion Rovers,Berwick Rangers,Cowdenbeath and East Stirlingshire are all in the bottom 6. Just shows that these teams were kept in the SPFL too long and a full pyramid system with B teams is the way to go as Rangers suggested.
new rules/regs introduced have been further introduced to stop teams progressing ie having Doctors at games etc is just one of things introduced ,not saying its a bad thing but it certainly discourages clubs as they have to have it in place before even attempting the playoffs as Buckie Thistle found to their cost at the end of the season even though 5 league clubs didn't meet the criteria
 
It’s a still a closed shop , clubs like Pollok,Talbot ,Clydebank need snookers to get promoted , even then they will move the goalposts
 
Why did the SFA ever do away with the reserve league? It was good to get injured players back to fitness and playing competitively

I know Celtic and hearts b teams play in the lowland league but where does Aberdeen Dundee b teams play?

The reserve league is still there us and them pulled out of it because we were playing the same players as they did through the age groups. St Johnstone pulled out cause they couldn't afford to run a reserve team.

It started in January and you only played each other once. Its only 10 teams now Dundee Hibs Killie and Livingston were the only ones that had a team in it last season.
 
Back
Top