Not sure I agree with all you said VB but debate is healthy!
As long it stays respectful and it has.
Doubt we have the funds to replace all 3 plus Macauley will also be replaced so that makes 4.Don’t think that would make Gerrard look too good replacing all four ………but you may be right.
Only one person knows for sure!
Ha ha, no worries mate. I did suggest funding would mean one of Katic or Goldson being a regular next season. I’d see the other as backup. So 2 new centre-backs, one a starter. But alongside which of Goldson/Katic? I seem out on my own with the view that there’s not a lot between Goldson, Katic and Worrall but I’m OK with that LOL. Simply don’t think Goldson is as good as he’s made out to be nor Worrall as bad as some would have you believe.
That’s a thing.
All the good potential we read about in the reserves and unders and there isn’t a centre back amongst them
I think you need to go back to the fifteen year old to find our best prospect.
Happy to be wrong here.
Dont know what our deal with Forest was , but splitting up Goldson and Katic was a mistake on the part of the manager , defending is all about partnerships and Goldson and Katic compliment each other better than the other pairing .
The Dutch player came to Scotland and cemented his place in the team every week...he had ups and downs not unlike many Dutch players he could be overconfident but he was streets ahead of Katic-he's an absolute man mountain a good 4 inches taller and a better player all round.
Katic could become a very good player-you're the one making outlandish claims-there's no need for it.
You couldn’t get anymore dramatic FF over the top than this post. Comparing Katic to Cuellar on today’s performance I’d say get your eyes checked.
Ikpeazu rolled Katic easily more than once today. He also has a knack of letting the ball bounce before going for it.
It’s an ok performance but he has so much to learn and improve from. SG obviously thinks the same as he’s been reluctant to use him all season. We all want the big man to do well but let’s not get carried away by a 6 or 7/10 performance.
Sounds like we’ve got a Worrall fan here. Katic put in some brilliant displays early in the season when our games were still competitive. There may be a lot of hyperbole in the OP but people are right to be happy with his recent inclusion ahead of a player whom the gaffers seems to have a huge blind spot with.
He did get rolled on one occasion, but he’ll learn and Goldson is pretty much giving a gaff a game just now but without the same sort of criticism.
The player Taz is speaking of is a prominent poster on here.
He’s playing with you a bit though.
He’s made the stat sound impressive.
The poster played at a decent level but not top division.
I don’t think he was ever full time.
He played one game against a Rangers eleven and that was in a testimonial.
The whole work went to that game, made up half the crowd, I think.
We lost 6-2 and the poster scored one of the goals.
One game, one goal.
Katic had a good game today bar one error that almost cost us. Credit to him for that and it came on the back of a good performance at Motherwell also. He certainly has it in him.
This myth of how solid we were at the start of the season with him and Goldson is just that though. We conceded more goals and dropped more points in the first 10 league games than we did in the last 10 that Goldson and Worrall started. The fact is, there is not an awful lot to choose between Goldson (who seems to largely get a free pass) and Worrall and Katic.
Worrall will be gone soon so I’m pleased to see Katic come in and perform well. If he had the money to spare I think Gerrard would replace all three of them next season but other priorities will see at least one of Katic or Goldson a regular starter next term. I wouldn’t bet on which one it will be.
Yeah but Katic and Goldson went through some extremely tough European ties at a time when a brand new team was still gelling. Worrall was in there to sit at the back against shite SPL teams who quite often never got in our half of the pitch. It also helps that he had the luxury of being continually selected after fùcking up as opposed to being hung out to dry like Katic.
I don’t care what anyone says, Gerrard got it wrong with Worrall, it was a mistake and one that I hope he’s learned from.
Listen I might be totally wrong here but was there not stuff going on in the big mans private life?? Plus the fact listen to the press conference with Gerrard about him when he first came. He is still a young young boy playing in a country miles from his home. Don't know who he has here with him but I wouldn't like to send a young 20 year old to Croatia. We as fans just expect these young guys to come here and perform. They can't even go to the supermarket and buy what they have grown up eating.
I don’t and Katic is hardly getting a lot of game time is he? We do know gerrard drove down to Brighton to convince Goldson to come to us and he pushed the worrall deal through on loan also. He has his two favourites in worrall and Goldson and doesn’t drop them when they make mistakes unlike Katic.
I have liked him from day one, especially when he was interview and told that the game here is more physical to which he answered" I like playing against physical players"
Whatever happened after August when he was dropped is anyone's guess on here, but I like many are glad to see the "Bigman " back.
He will be a great CB in years to come.