Overrated players?

[dt17]

Roberto Carlos

Fair to say there'd be a debate as to who was better between him and Marcelo?

 

[Davie Weir]

Dele Alli

Was a fantastic talent when he signed for Spurs and broke though in their first team, sky was the limit for him.

Never came close to what he could have done imo

 

[baystatebear]

Speaking of being overrated - a place on the list has to be found for Raheem Sterling

 

[GazRanger]

Jota at Liverpool,absolutely garbage. Watch him for portugal and see how angry ronaldo gets everytime he gives the ball away

 

[tazzabear]

Van Dyke for me is one of the most over rated players of the modern era.

Looked good in a scum team against no competition who were always exposed in Europe and now looking good in a Premier League era where, let's be honest here, doesn't have a deep pool of quality strikers compared to past eras.

Kane, Vardy, Zaha, Rashford, etc compared to the likes of Drogba, peak Rooney, Henry, Shearer? No wonder he looks good.

In the “hard to believe” category, that’s going to take a bit of beating.

 

[Chinggis_could_I_khant]

Karol Józef Wojtyła. Treated like a god in Poland. Can't go into anywhere in Krakow without there being a picture of him. At best a semi-decent keeper.

And don't get me started on that Pavarotti bloke!

 

[dt17]

Andy Robertson