Sfa release guidance on players being cited

[uneasydaz]

Bobby Madden a liar then

 

[ElBarrileteCosmico]

The Compliance Officer asks one fundamental question: was it the huns?

 

[georgedoors]

These scum will always make it up as they go collum had eyes in the back of his head seeing candieas and the picture in op clearly shows unobstructed view

 

[shoulderpads]

Bobby Madden a liar then

Off the ball incident? No.
Obscured view? No.
Bobby?

 

[TNT]

Clear as mud then.

 

[deedle]

This is to cover themselves from accusations that they are re-refereeing games.

It isn't credible to claim that Madden never saw the incident but that's the line they're taking.

 

[The Goal Machine]

Not answering the one important thing, what is the procedure to identify an incident?

 

[Axelrod]

And still they won’t tell us who decides which incidents are referred in the first place .

 

[SB·]

They can only avoid reworking the system if they publish an explanation for each decision in detail. Until then, even these guidelines can be shown as not being adhered to consistently. It's nonsense.

 

[Professor Yaffle]

Amateur hour once again and Jobby Midden is a liar

 

[Sutton_Blows_goats]

Well thats just out and out lies - why even release that?

 

[Super A]

Misses the point

'When an incident has been identified'.

Who does the identifying ?
Players
Managers
Fans
Sportscene
The compliance officer
Joe from the CSA.

Then does the compliance officer refer all those back to the ref, did you see it? did you see it all?

If not then why not?

Pretty fundamental I would have thought.
100s of mins for televised football each week so whats the method of making the compliance officer aware?

 

[Labboy]

Depends on how the scum on sportscene see it, also Rangers guilty all the time, filth the lot of them

 

[StuGers]

I’ve said it before, the SFA aren’t even trying hard with their lies on why they continually punish us.

They are simply not fit for purpose. The game is a bogey as long as they are in charge.

 

[Arkanoid]

Guidance released in February! Lying, incompetent, bigoted scum
Welcome to Scottish football folks

 

[allyscott]

Also need guidance on what happens to officials who lie.

 

[Porto Loyal]

Misses the point

'When an incident has been identified'.

Who does the identifying ?

Precisely. I beleive it’s the staff in the SFA disciplinary department, but what criteria they use is not known

 

[RFC_Champions]

Statement says:

.......when an incident has been identified to the compliance officer......

What if fails to explain is how or who raised/identifies any incidents!!!!

Economical with the truth big time!

 

[kclarkhall]

Also need guidance on what happens to officials who lie.

And clubs that allowed children to be abused?

 

[BrunoseAlves]

Utterly ridiculous. How do you determine if an incident has been seen 'in its' entirety'? Even the referee can never be sure of that. So who decides if the refs view was 'perfect'?

The entire system is subjective and designed to be abused.

 

[Nerf Herder]

So still no addressing the fact its the Biased Broadcasting Corporation or scum fans on their couch that are raising most of the complaints around us to the compliance officer.

Statement means nothing.

 

[Three-in-seven]

Utterly ridiculous. How do you determine if an incident has been seen 'in its' entirety'? Even the referee can never be sure of that. So who decides if the refs view was 'perfect'?

The entire system is subjective and designed to be abused.

That is their get out of jail free card.

Madden could not win in that situation, could he?

They ask him, "did you see that incident in it's entirety?"

He answers "No" McGregor gets cited.

He answers "Yes"

He will then be vilified for not sending McGregor off for a supposedly dangerous challenge.

There will be uproar because in some simpletons heads he has cheated ceptic, even though they were nothing to do with the game in question.

Easy option, deny seeing the incident 'in its' entirety'.

Get out of jail free.

 

[sofakineazy]

Not answering the one important thing, what is the procedure to identify an incident?

They tune into BBC Sportscene and the BBC shows all the incidents involving Rangers which the BBC decides should be put forward and omit any other incidents involving 'ra sellik.

 

[Byson]

Bobby Madden a liar then

Makes a complete farce of that. Fucking bastards

 

[Southsideblueblood]

Wait a minute , the Hibs player got booked against Celtic. What did the referee no see? Which shitehawk wrote this fairy tale.

 

[Amato Amore]

Not answering the one important thing, what is the procedure to identify an incident?

I refer you to the first reply on this thread by @ElBarrileteCosmico

 

[Sir Walter]

Maybe Dave King can call out Madden now for his blatant lies?

 

[gersmad]

procedure to identify an incident

Sportscene show repeats in detail of Rangers players, with the scums it's nothing to see here.

 

[Kerr Johnston]

Been to Steve Clarke school of lying