Should we sign Shankland in January?

[Sheik Ma Shammy]

He done ok, far better than Burke done.

I just don't see what Burke offers a team he's just a big lad who's quick but has no real talent.

 

[Realger34]

I just don't see what Burke offers a team he's just a big lad who's quick but has no real talent.

Head down and runs into trouble constantly, he’s rotten.

 

[Realger34]

Shankland got 45mins last night for Scotland. How did he do?

I never saw the match.

I should elaborate a wee bit mate, he held the ball up well and brought others into play but the game was getting played in our 18 yard box most of the time.

 

[Southside_shug]

I was talking to a couple of guys int eh pub who told me he had a two week trial with Kilmarnock last year and Clark didn't fancy him then. Allegedly Boydie said at the time that he was a no-no too.

No one could work out , other than his 65 goals in the past 65 games why he was been selected!!!

 

[Luca Stroppi]

Don’t think he’s quite good enough and definitely not in favour of giving that diddy club any cash. We can get better and furthermore, we need to be more proactive in identifying talent at an early stage and not when they move to diddy clubs who want to hold us to ransom over the fee.

 

[Dave570]

Sign him and send him back to Ayr on loan to keep Dundee Hibs down?!

Is that worth paying a couple of Million for which DU will price him at as soon as we appear interested. I hear them already "Oh you mean our Scottish International top scorer that means, money money money!"

 

[prenzlauerbear]

I thought Joe Worrall threw him about like an empty tracky when we played them in the cup last year.

 

[Sir Sasa Papac]

I like him but I can’t think of one game he would have played for us this year, even as a sub. He wouldn’t get a chance at us and I don’t think a substitute appearance every few months would work

 

[DJ Blue]

No thread this week ?

Wonder why.

Queen of the South 4 Dundee U 0

 

[Crown_Defender]

No thread this week ?

Wonder why.

Queen of the South 4 Dundee U 0

Dont do irony do you mate?

 

[Dylanbear]

No thread this week ?

Wonder why.

Queen of the South 4 Dundee U 0

Dobbie with a double, I have a large collection of butt-plugs

 

[VMS]

Not for me plus I would not give his scum club one penny SG didn't want him for free so cant see why he would want to pay a fee for him now

 

[Tugay83]

I would take a punt on him. Surely wouldn’t cost that much.

We don't need that sort of player though. Defoe does the job Shankland would be doing if he signed and he's been brilliant as a backup option to Morelos.

 

[Whosthedado9]

We don't need that sort of player though. Defoe does the job Shankland would be doing if he signed and he's been brilliant as a backup option to Morelos.

Absolutely agree about Defoe , but Shankland would learn so much from him and would be decent to have as a third striker incase we have injuries / suspensions up front

 

[Bumplittledipper]

If signing Nicky Clark taught us anything, its don't sign another Nicky Clark.

 

[Bee-D]

Should maybe ha e took him when he was at Ayr utd. Now those scumdee hivs will want a fortune for him. Please dont fund them Rangers.

 

[yardie]

FFS, we are a proper big club again.

 

[Geerfc19]

Sam cosgrove?