Numanloyal
Well-Known Member
Bob Valentine v Rangers , Scottish cup Finals of 1977 & 1989
Yep. Waddle. 10 year old Battlefield Bear hated that arsewipe.Andrew Waddell. Any game. Particular highlights include the game against Hamilton at Ibrox and the Scottish Cup semi vs the filth.
77 scf.Could be the 89 final I mentioned or even the 77 final
Clancy at the Piggery 100%.
Easily the worst I’ve seen in 50 years.
At least 5 game changing decisions all wrong & all wrong in their favour.
Vote for this , and being number due to it costing us to lose, I still can’t work out how a rugby tackle by mcgregor lead to a foul against AlfieBeaton against Hibs.
That was the worst performance and exhibition of bias and bigotry I have ever seen in a football game. I regret to say that hasn't got much better.Beaton v Hibs and it's not even close.
It's not that he got one or two high profile decisions wrong, he got every single decision wrong. He lost control after about 15 minutes.
Came on to post this exactly mate . Unbelievably let Roy Aitken take what was a blatant Rangers throw in1989 OF maybe, ruled out a good Butcher goal & I’m sure let Roy Aitken take a throw in that was very dubious, they scored from said throw.
This for meAndrew Waddell. Any game. Particular highlights include the game against Hamilton at Ibrox and the Scottish Cup semi vs the filth.
Like you, I've seen some truly terrible refereeing over a long period of time, dating back over 50 years watching Rangers, but Clancy at the piggery is actually the first time I've genuinely BELIEVED that the referee was just a cheat.
Simple as that. A cheat. That's never happened with me before.
Another dishonourable mention for Beaton v Hibs. Truly horrific display that day, as well.
This. One being outright cheating. The other being pure incompetence.Clancy at the Piggery and Beaton at the Hibs game
Andrew Waddell. Any game. Particular highlights include the game against Hamilton at Ibrox and the Scottish Cup semi vs the filth.
Plus the extra time at the end of the game where he added on another two minutes on top of the injury time hoping they'd get an equaliser.Clancy at the Piggery 100%.
Easily the worst I’ve seen in 50 years.
At least 5 game changing decisions all wrong & all wrong in their favour.
Plus the extra time at the end of the game where he added on another two minutes on top of the injury time hoping they'd get an equaliser.
Well, there are no plenty of examples, mostly in recent times. There are two that stand out for me:
The 5-5 game against Hibs in the last game of the season. Blatant penalty claims and sending offs summarily ignored.
The other is Clancy’s performance in the victory at Porkheid las year. Summed up for me by making Davis walk past the Orc hordes near the end of the game and the extra added time. That’s without going into the penalties, handballs and other incidents.
How he avoided investigation is a mystery.
He still played in the final.77 final
incidentally, john greig was sent off the week before in the last league game at pitodrie which made him miss the final.
the referee at pittodrie?, valentine. who did the final one week later.
Yes, Khenny was competent, but a cheat. IIRC, well-known for being Sellik minded in Barrhead.Who was the guy who loved the attention, Kenny Clark?. I’m sure he had a few howlers in older games I’ve watched.
Clancy without a shadow of doubt.Reading about Craig Thomson in the St Mirren 9 man cup final got me wondering, what is the worst referee performance in one of our games in a domestic game?
Beaton's refereeing in the 2-3 game v Hibs when he sent off Ryan Jack is the angriest I have been leaving the ground from memory.
His refereeing of last February's Kilmarnock 2-1 game comes a close second.
Off topic I know but Kenny Clark’s refereeing of the Clyde v Celtic cup tie was as bad a cheating referee performance as you will ever see.Who was the guy who loved the attention, Kenny Clark?. I’m sure he had a few howlers in older games I’ve watched.
I can’t recall mate but I will take your word for it!.Off topic I know but Kenny Clark’s refereeing of the Clyde v Celtic cup tie was as bad a cheating referee performance as you will ever see.
Very close second , although I thought Beaton shat it that day.Beaton v hibs for me
This for me. Beyond just having an 'off day'. Proper cheating and Micheal Beale called him out on that too.Clancy at the Piggery even though we won
But Valentine was a cnut in that game.
First 2 I thought ofClancy at the Piggery and Beaton at the Hibs game
That Hibs game was mental. Remember scraps outside the Copland coming out of the game. Also Caixinha's last game, 1-1 Killie at Ibrox, we're 1-0 up, 6 minutes added on and we get a penalty 2 minutes in, ridiculous protests from Killie players and a red card for Jack. Penalty gets taken about 3 minutes later, Candeias misses and they go up the other end and equalise right away. Blows the full-time whistle and I swear to god you're lucky if we played half of the injury time.Reading about Craig Thomson in the St Mirren 9 man cup final got me wondering, what is the worst referee performance in one of our games in a domestic game?
Beaton's refereeing in the 2-3 game v Hibs when he sent off Ryan Jack is the angriest I have been leaving the ground from memory.
His refereeing of last February's Kilmarnock 2-1 game comes a close second.
I remember being in back of the broomloan and the whole stadium singing ‘waddell get tae %^*&, waddell, waddell get tae %^*&’ - he was instantly the first guy that came to mindAndrew Waddell. Any game. Particular highlights include the game against Hamilton at Ibrox and the Scottish Cup semi vs the filth.
Willie Young was the ref that day.Without reading through all the threads, in my opinion Andrew Waddell's refereeing of the SCF in 98 is utterly the most biased I have ever seen in my life.
Hearts get a penalty a yard outside the box, we get a free kick a yard inside the box, it was f ucking outrageous decisions, but hardly anything was made of it.
The result would have been the other way about if not for that c unt.
He was also involved in other shockers but that was the worst.
Not against us but Ian Brynes deserves a mention for gifting the mentally challengeds the league in 2008 by disallowing the perfect headed winner in the last minute for a "mistaken" handball.
Obviously Clancy & Thomson too many to mention.
Anyway f duck then all 55 is on it's way. WATP
This is the one that always springs to mind. A plethora of inexplicable decisions.Beaton against Hibs.