Yellow card for hand ball
- Thread starter Tpol_rfc
- Start date
Jimnycricket
Well-Known Member
If there is an element of stopping an attack, unsporting behaviour, for tactical reasons or trying to deceive the referee.
Lemmy
Well-Known Member
Being Alfie or wearing blue.
ChildOfGoth
Well-Known Member
That’s a Q I had is it mandatory to caution someone when it hits there arm in the box and they did not play towards it as such.
Prick also cautioned Hagi for encroaching and loads of people done exact same and weren’t .
A flagrant cheat pure and simple
Prick also cautioned Hagi for encroaching and loads of people done exact same and weren’t .
A flagrant cheat pure and simple
Todd The Prod
Well-Known Member
I didn’t think Morelos should’ve been booked for it tbh.
It wasn’t deliberate, his hand/arm was down by his side.
Was it a penalty? Aye it was. A harsh one, but one that we would be wanting if it were us.
It wasn’t deliberate, his hand/arm was down by his side.
Was it a penalty? Aye it was. A harsh one, but one that we would be wanting if it were us.
Clancy has Buffs name on yellow card before games start
pepsimax73
Well-Known Member
Why was the ball played hand rule stopped the only way to stop it would be strap players arms up
Ubik
Well-Known Member
No it wasn't due to the clear double handed push just before it.
frankie_dux
Well-Known Member
Penalty should have been retaken as well
Todd The Prod
Well-Known Member
Didn’t see a push? Not seen any replays yet.
the upsetter
Well-Known Member
Hard not to believe that if McGregor had saved it the penalty would have been retaken.
Bigbluebear
Well-Known Member
Under the current rules that should maybe be a penalty, however its fucking nonsense. What was he meant to do with his arm there? He's trying to pull it out the way.
Clancy would have sent Morelos off if he had a chance, could see him watching him after the ball was away from him to see if he could book him for anything.
Clancy would have sent Morelos off if he had a chance, could see him watching him after the ball was away from him to see if he could book him for anything.
Ubik
Well-Known Member
eh, are you ignoring the clear foul for us before this even becomes an issue?
gusty2
Well-Known Member
This.
ChildOfGoth
Well-Known Member
What is the new handball rule?
An explanation of the new handball rule introduced for the 2020-21 season.
www.bbc.co.uk
I’m not seeing where it was a foul and hence penalty and can’t see it said you must caution either
Handball Rule in Football | Deliberate Ball Handling Rules - UK Rules
HANDBALL IN FOOTBALL: FIFA handball rule governs the intentional or the deliberate ball handling and accidental ball touching offences. Handball rules and regulations in football are the most controversial laws for English Premier League referees and linesmen to handle. Determining the...
www.theukrules.co.uk
The only line that justifies his judgement tonight is that was a deliberate handball and that is why he cautioned him . Was it ? I believe clearly Not .
Edit : OP caution is Not mandatory as far as I can see in thst link it’s linked to intentional act I think
Last edited:
Bear all
Well-Known Member
Would I be wanting you bet you’re bottom dollar I would ,would we get no chance.
Clancey should just book Alfie coming off the bus and get it over with.
Dean Learner
Well-Known Member
It’s never even close to a booking but Clancy always finds a way to get Alfie’s name in the book.
tazzabear
Well-Known Member
Would that cover Brown’s quite disgusting behaviour towards Kent then Tavernier after the sending off?
Clart Simpson
Member
Agree it was a pen but def not a yellow, I don’t think Clancy is biased he is just a pish all round referee
TJ Newton
Active Member
That’s Beaton your thinking about. You’re correct that Clancy isn’t biased; he’s a cheat with a litany of previous.
scottyfrancis1996
Well-Known Member
With the handball, if it was on target (which I don't think it was and Alfie did it deliberate and arm was higher than his shoulder, it's a red but cos of where his arm was and didn't look like it was going in, Clancy did the right thing with a yellow we'd be screaming for the same if it was the other end if you watch the hand closely
ChildOfGoth
Well-Known Member
Don’t think so senior have a read of the rules links above .
I’m not clear it was a pen at all only would be if his arm was making himself bigger or it was deliberate handball which I can’t clearly determine . Maybe you can ?
scottyfrancis1996
Well-Known Member
I'm a former referee (yes I was better as I was always fair to every team), and I knew his arm wasn't making him look bigger but his arm was out from the natural position
hms
Well-Known Member
There was a push before the header so it should’ve been a foul.
It wasn’t a yellow card, Alfie didn’t intentionally handball, it was ball to hand.
It was a penalty under the new rules but it was not a yellow card as it wasn’t intentional.
Just another honest mistake from Clancy
It wasn’t a yellow card, Alfie didn’t intentionally handball, it was ball to hand.
It was a penalty under the new rules but it was not a yellow card as it wasn’t intentional.
Just another honest mistake from Clancy
therealmackay
Well-Known Member
Not good enough, only solution is to amputate all players except the keepers before taking the field of play.
The whole handball rule has descended into a total farce now and is only likely to get worse.
TerryMunro
Well-Known Member
If that penalty was missed it would of been retaken. The ref even indicated that he noticed the ball moving.
