Var has got every offside correct.
Clean up the handball rule (not just in scotland) and itll be close to perfect.
Maby be a tad quicker aswell.
He wants it scrapped because before especially with offsides his club always got the benefit of doubt.
A tad quicker? needs to be almost instant.
As it stands right now, i think the time some decisions take and the way they break the momentum of games, never mind the amount of time they add, are VAR's biggest weak point.
This 'time difference' might also be the biggest danger to the game as we know it and be the catalyst for wholesale changes.
How long were some games during the world cup? Fark me, players hanging out and breaking every time there was a 'big decision'. Didn't look all that different from American sport to me. I wonder what FIFA would think about more advertising slots during a game? Would they care if it bothered 'legacy' supporters? Or fark them and follow the cash?
Would you trust FIFA to make the correct choice?
I am not liking VAR in it's current set up. It is shite.
Maybe we need two referees on the park, one each end. Maybe they need to be Pro's themselves. Maybe they hire themselves out from an accredited European pool to leagues to stop accusations of bias. The better you are, the more you could charge for a big game.
Plenty could be done to improve refereeing, systems that could double check referee's might improve to a point where they could take over games, something a bit like VAR, only one that works.
VAR needs vastly improved before it changes the game forever. Sadly, the game will be changed for the worst, ruined no doubt, but by then it will be too late, we wont be able to go back.