Brown Tackle vs Broadfoot Tackle

[Edweird]

I see little difference between these two challenges other than the color of the card and of course Walker's opinion.
There was also a point in the first half I think Brown handled the ball. About 5 seconds later Killie got a free kick on the edge of the box and it was never revisited.
The gap is now 8 points and we can argue that Madden is indirectly (or directly) responsible for 4 of those.

 

[Bobans27]

Both are reds.....

 

[CaptainObjective]

Both are reds.....

This is the correct answer.

 

[Axelrod]

Browns is worse . Fact .

 

[PortoyMortoy]

One is a celtic player who has been protected for a decade now the other is a Killie player who made a tackle on a celtic player when they still hadn't got their goal yet. You could flip the names on the tackle and the cards would still go to the same players. There wont be any media outcry though as it's the team they want these type of calls to benefit them that got it

 

[Oshahoorsir]

Take your pick of red or yellow but both are worth same card.

 

[Beer Belly Loyal]

Game is fecked if Brown stays on the park.

 

[bornabluenose]

Both reds , Broadfoot let those fuckers out of jail , stupid lunge .

Brown is a protected species.

 

[JD1872]

Both are miles worse that what Morelos did and nowhere near as bad as the challenge on Jack

 

[bear wi nae hair]

It just shows you how easy it is to set the agenda doesn’t it.

Browns is a straight leg with studs into the opposing players standing leg but Walker keeps his tempo and tone the same and calls it a yellow. Nothing to see here. The correct punishment has been handed out.

 

[Family bam]

Both reds but as we all know inTIMidation has worked perfectly for the cheating mentally challenged bastards.

NS.

 

[Fox & Hounds]

Not real. Then he goes and scores the goal. What is interesting is how little the ceptic players backchat the ref. They have been told to button it.

 

[Henrywatson115]

the fact madden sent him off will mean the CO can't give him 2 or 3 game ban

 

[kingstonbear]

Brown seems to have one of those tackles every week. Not sure he’s seen a red for any of them.

 

[Davie Meiklejohn]

Taking someone shin high on the ground at speed, versus coming down on someone's foot in the air. There's no doubt Madden did what he had to do.

 

[Buzz07]

Both red card tackles.
Be interesting to see if the Trampy Kilmarnock says anything.

 

[steve1873]

Browns is worse . Fact .

Correct. The guys foot is planted. That in itself makes it worse.

Both are reds however.

But Brown is a protected species.

 

[Mview83]

Brown’s initial tackle not even being mentioned by sky in the post match interviews or analysed at all. They have the media all sewn up.

 

[Clubdeck]

Both reds, but looking for retrospective action is a waste of time, he got a red in the end, so it won't make any difference now.

Had he been sent off during the game mind you...

 

[si72]

Pair of pricks.

 

[Sebrof61]

the fact madden sent him off will mean the CO can't give him 2 or 3 game ban

probably knew what he was doing

 

[Kingging]

Doesn't help us to make a comparison in this case. Broadfoot deserved red all day long. Of course Brown should already have been off but it's probably better just to concentrate on the shit he repeatedly gets away with

 

[BlueMalky]

the fact madden sent him off will mean the CO can't give him 2 or 3 game ban

Sorry Henry, but if he’s if he’s been sent off for two bookings then the first one can be revisited. It’ll be interesting to see if Midden comes out and says he didn’t see everything so they can upgrade it. What they can’t do is change the effect the mongo had after that

 

[Coda]

Madden once again desperately trying to prove he’s not a Rangers fan.

Utter arsehole of a man.

 

[bigduds58]

Point is though even if he gets a ban they won the match because he was still on the pitch now think of Morelos red at Aberdeen we lost two points because the ref fuked it up

 

[Mr.Spock]

When Steve Clarke finishes having a beer with the manager of his favourite team I wonder if he'll make any comment about the inconsistency of ref calls just as he did last week about one of our games.

 

[Eddie Doc]

Anybody hear what Clarke had to say about this? His beloved fukn hoops.

 

[Scottland]

How many times does this rat get away with these sort of challenges. Well played Broadfoot anyway.

 

[Jamiegatami]

Sportscene - Brown yellow. Broadfoot Red.

 

[amabluestar]

the fact madden sent him off will mean the CO can't give him 2 or 3 game ban

Was going to ask that.
Can mongo's yellow be upgraded to red to go along with the red he got?

 

[Mview83]

Sportscene - Brown yellow. Broadfoot Red.

Well I never

 

[charlie_snowball]

Broadfoot's is arguably far more in control that Brown's.

Both are stick on reds though.

 

[northeast6]

Both reds but Browns reaction helped get broadfoot sent off if the killie player did the same by rolling about then mayb just mayb brown would have got red

 

[Viper_RFC]

Broadfoots was slightly more obvious- but both clear reds and Ref has failed to do his job!

 

[weebaggy]

Both yellows.

Why is Kirkwoods worse than Powers last week?

Or was he on a yellow?

 

[Family bam]

Sportscene - Brown yellow. Broadfoot Red.

Sportscene - Boyd is a fat orange bastard.

Broadfoot - Red.

NS.

 

[final_straws]

I didn't think either were reds tbh.

Objectively, in real time I don't think Brown's was particularly out of control or wild (well certainly not as bad as others have been). I know it was a straight leg but I still think yellow was correct.

Broadfoot's was soft however he was certainly looking to leave his mark & it was very late. Still think it is a yellow a lot of the time though.

 

[AndyWebsterLoyal]

Sportscene - Brown yellow. Broadfoot Red.

All about the biomechanics

 

[Let’s Gio]

I see little difference between these two challenges other than the color of the card and of course Walker's opinion.
There was also a point in the first half I think Brown handled the ball. About 5 seconds later Killie got a free kick on the edge of the box and it was never revisited.
The gap is now 8 points and we can argue that Madden is indirectly (or directly) responsible for 4 of those.

That’s the same ref that gave power a yellow?

 

[Horace goes Skiing]

Brown's was a yellow. People let their hatred get in the way of rationality.

 

[Highland Gers]

Both red. Brown has made a career out of tackles like that- and getting away with it

 

[Burgh-Ger]

Browns was above the boys ankle, it’s a red!

Broadfoots was a red as well!

 

[azoots217]

Both reds , Broadfoot let those fuckers out of jail , stupid lunge .

Brown is a protected species.

Protected species yes ,species of what no one knows

 

[Mondraker]

Brown's was a yellow. People let their hatred get in the way of rationality.

Straight leg, studs up and into the opponents standing leg.

Red card.

 

[Edweird]

That’s the same ref that gave power a yellow?

Not sure but he red carded Morelos who got a three match ban. With him yesterday we may have had 3 points. Without Brown Tims would most likely not have won.
In the past two weeks I've seen Madden:
Aberdeen player incident: RED
Rangers player incident :RED
Killie player incident : RED
Celtic player incident : Yellow.
Look at the top 4 teams in the league and who won out.
If this does even itself out over a season we'll win the league by ten points and the filth will be relegated.

 

[Calico Jack]

Brown's was a yellow. People let their hatred get in the way of rationality.

Rubbish.

Brown went in studs up on a player with a planted foot, after the ball was gone.

Broadfoots was in the air, with an open boot.

Brown's was more dangerous, by far.

 

[Calico Jack]

Straight leg, studs up and into the opponents standing leg.

Red card.

Absolutely agree.

It was a cowards challange.

I wish someone would just snap the Phenian c un t

 

[Jock MacHarg]

the fact madden sent him off will mean the CO can't give him 2 or 3 game ban

Madden needs to remember that another day is coming.

 

[DavyPik]

Brown's was a yellow. People let their hatred get in the way of rationality.

I think Horace is going fishing this time
Browns was off the ground straight legged and caught the man half way up his shin. Worse than McGregor.
Broadfoot was nowhere near as high as Power.
The only thing that’s consistent is that we miss out every fecking time.
Steve Clarke may surprise me and have something to say but I very much doubt it

 

[Ibroxkev]

Both reds and a completely different game if they were down to 10 for the second half.