Barker or Jones?

[1914-18]

As back up to Kent who would you rather out of the 2? Obviously Jones is way out the picture with the management team but on their day who would you rather in the team as back up to Kent?

I think we would all like better but these 2 are the ones currently in the squad

 

[Diego Maradona]

I voted barker as he’s less of a liability

 

[PT98]

If Jones was fully focused and professional I would choose him.

He isnt though so would go with Barker.

 

[giogaddi]

Prefer neither but Barker if pushed. Mainly on account of him not being a rocket.

 

[JerseyLoyalist]

Jones for me.

 

[LordCraig]

Prefer neither but Barker if pushed. Mainly on account of him not being a rocket.

Sums it up for me

 

[Clubdeckg]

Jones clearly isn't in the picture, hopefully he moves on soon. Need an upgrade on Barker though

 

[AzorIbrox]

Jones every day of the week.

Excellent in last years Europa qualifying campaign and played well away to Motherwell earlier in the season.

He should be the one coming on for Kent when he's not at it.

 

[JD1872]

Both have had their last chance to impress this season and haven’t taken it IMHO

 

[Main Stand]

I think Barker suits our system better & has better in game intelligence/tactical discipline, but I think Jones is a better player.

Undecided.

 

[Kit_]

I chose Barker cause I couldn’t stop laughing at this.

https://twitter.com/x/status/1250634763703955457

 

[Milger72]

Jones for me. But he has absolutely ruined his Rangers career. Daft boy will regret it.

 

[blueismycolour]

Honesty, could we not just get someone else and offload those two.

 

[Captain Gough]

I think if Barker had some of jones’ confidence, he’d be a good player. Unfortunately, I just think the jersey is too big for him. A shame as he is talented.

 

[mck1872]

Jay Emanuel Thomas.

 

[alba73]

Stewart

 

[LaudrupTheGreat]

Jones if he could be bothered

 

[Beckhambear2]

Jones 100%

 

[GallowgateBlue]

I went for Jones. He has had some good performances for us. One player that still really annoys me on how he hasn't done more though. I think he has what is required but seems to lack the application and nut to really hunker down. I do still live in hope he does it, proba not mind.

 

[Hank_Marvin]

Purely based on what I've seen from both in a Rangers shirt, Jones.

However I'd have punted both and gave Kai Kennedy the game time

 

[S English]

For a more accurate poll neither should have been an option, but if forced to pick one it has to be Barker

 

[Rickymck]

Meh!

 

[55 and counting]

Barker. I think he comes in for some heavy unmerited criticism on here at times. He is a frustration admittedly as I do believe it's all there. But seems to lack belief. Maybe suffers from imposter syndrome.

 

[Myc74]

I dont particularly rate either of them but went for Barker as at least he applies himself.
Jones is a talented boy but a f.uckin idiot

 

[Burnbankblue]

Jones all day long, Barker is not a good player.

 

[cradletograve]

Neither would be a choice for me.
Picked Jones because when he puts in the work he offers more. Such a shame his lack of professionalism lets him down. Can't even put it down to daftboyness any more. He's wasted his talent. If he had the application of, say, Andy Halliday he'd be a superstar. Imho

 

[Thasunke Witko]

I think Barker suits our system better & has better in game intelligence/tactical discipline, but I think Jones is a better player.

Undecided.

This is why barker got the nod from me, disappointed in jones because I really think he could be a cracker if he had his head screwed on and took advice on.

 

[BoyciesDa]

None of them

 

[Macky]

I voted Jones purely cause Barker has never done anything of note in any of his many chances on the pitch. Jones seems to be a bit of a rocket but far more effective.

If anything Stewart has actually been more effective than both though.

 

[Tucker7]

Jones for me time we gave him another chance Kent needs a rest

 

[IbroxForever]

No debate for me, voted Jones.

 

[irvine96]

Jones the better player but neither are good enough for our club and should be punted

 

[Coatbridge Chancellor]

Neither really. But Barker.

 

[coplandron]

Jones is the better player but sadly is an idiot.

 

[Big D]

Rather we got rid of both and used the combined wages for an upgrade tbh.

 

[Optimus_Prime]

To think jones has only played ten times for us. Can’t see that increasing so barker for me.

 

[Broxbound Bear]

Barker by a country mile. It's not even close.

 

[DJ_RFC_1872]

Both not good enough

 

[bob1873]

I voted barker as he’s less of a liability

Yip first reply nailed it. Jones is decent but he’s liable to do something really stupid he’s already done 2. The second of which could have jeopardised our season.

 

[AdiGaz]

I think jones is maybe a better player but i wouldnt want him about my squad in all honesty

 

[20rangersultras07]

I honestly don’t see what everyone sees is Jones.

 

[Mac72]

In an ideal world neither of them. Jones is probably better on the ball and cab create something from nothing, whereas Barker is more tactically sound and less of fud.

Hopefully get wright in before the window ends and he can offer us a but more quality as a back up to Kent.

 

[Aragorn]

I think Jones shows a bit of grit on the rare occasion he plays...Barker nope.

 

[Kris1872]

Prefer neither but Barker if pushed. Mainly on account of him not being a rocket.

Nailed it.

 

[bear wi nae hair]

Tbh I’m going with option 3 - a traffic cone

Whilst not as mobile as the other 2 it doesn’t demand a weekly salary, it won’t go to parties and potentially affect the entire squad with Covid and it doesn’t have stupid chin strap face fuzz.

 

[Clubdeckg]

We need better than both

 

[RoyalBlue1]

Neither. Punt both and spend the profit on a professional.

 

[Al Needham Loyal]

Barker.

Far more professional, willing to take tactical instruction, and younger.

 

[RFC_Champions]

This poll should be how would you like your balls kicked?

Right foot or left foot.

 

[SouthCoastLoyal]

Jones has only played 176 minutes of football for us versus Barker who has played 607 minutes, I would go for Barker because I have hardly seen Jones play. Barker's passing accuracy is slightly higher than Jones too.