“That’s a fifth premiership penalty for Celtic, more than any other side”

[scottishpoet]

Didn't see that last week. It is actually that bad it is funny!

Was it checked with VAR?

Yes, they are all reviewed by VAR. VAR did not see anything to suggest the ref made a clear and obvious error so the decision to give a penalty stood

 

[Ruben Sosa]

It

There was a few on here at the time it happened trying to argue that it was a stonewaller

It's a free kick to Hearts.

 

[artificialintoleranz]

Yes, they are all reviewed by VAR. VAR did not see anything to suggest the ref made a clear and obvious error so the decision to give a penalty stood

Thanks for confirming.

Fair enough, if VAR checked and didn't see an issue, it must be a penalty then

 

[Blue Cowboy]

The one last week at Tynecastle , even Chris Sutton was embarrassed with the award.

The ref has been conned there. Kyogo has gone looking for contact and exaggerated it. VAR would just have checked and said yeah there was contact. Refs need to wise up.

 

[dazzapat]

It winds the tims up so fair game imo

I’m in a general football group chat that has a couple Tim’s in it. I just drop a ‘say those 3 magic words’ into it, and the response is always ‘Penalty to Rangers?’.

Howlin every time

 

[uneasydaz]

Kyogo was at it again last night

https://twitter.com/x/status/1720034437855908338

 

[DEJABLUE62]

Nope. Nor was it featured on Sky Ref Penalty watch for Dermot Gallagher to give his opinion on.

Excellent point strange that eh

 

[wee_bear]

Did Turnbull not get one for falling into someone earlier in the season also?

 

[BSPECIAL]

Something you won’t read about on KDS.
Last nights commentary on Sportscene.
To be honest, I didn’t expect to hear it there either!

We got our third in two matches.

 

[Badger]

The one last week at Tynecastle , even Chris Sutton was embarrassed with the award.

First time seeing that. What's the point in VAR if that's given as a pen.

 

[Badger]

That is pathetic. Pathetic the ref gave it, pathetic that VAR didn't overturn & pathetic that wee bowl cutted, tranny looking little weirdo took a dive in the first place.

All the handball pens that are given do my head in as well. No penalty claim that hits someone's hand should be decided by VAR. All handball's will look like pens slowed down 4-5 times on camera.

So the St Mirren player shouldn't have been sent off or would you allow it in cases like this, where its a deliberate attempt to play the ball with your hand?

 

[bkerr72]

I don't think it's soft. I don't think it's a penalty whatsoever.

I was going to caveat what I said regarding 'no penalty should be given for handball by VAR' with unless the referee wants to look at it, but I know that isn't a thing with VAR; or the referee has completely missed something. I think everyone missed the St Mirren one in real time so fair enough VAR worked properly for once.

90% of the penalty's we're seeing given, not just up here, but down south for handball to me are not penalties. These pens where players are getting balls thundered at them for 3-4 yards away are mental. A player cannot have their hands down by their side all the time when they are running and turning etc etc. I get the hands above the head as there is no real reason for that. I just think they are complicating the game for no real reason.

I suppose the best way to describe it is they are looking for penalties. You shouldn't need to 'look' for a penalty, it should be pretty clear.

Agree with you on the handball front but that's a failing of the handball rule itself and not VAR. The rule is needing changed big time but until then we'll keep seeing them being given.

 

[bkerr72]

Thanks for confirming.

Fair enough, if VAR checked and didn't see an issue, it must be a penalty then

They will have checked on the basis of what Walsh has told them he's seen to give the penalty. If he mentions he sees contact being made then that's it there's nothing to disprove it. As soon as Walsh gives that it isn't being overturned as soft as it is.

 

[Masonic Penny]

The one last week at Tynecastle , even Chris Sutton was embarrassed with the award.

Surely that wasn’t given as a penalty?
Soft as a babies shite.

 

[Coplandfrontier]

The one last week at Tynecastle , even Chris Sutton was embarrassed with the award.

Incredible that was given. Kyogo is the biggest diving cheat this country has witnessed.

 

[Jlakeman]

Penalty to the peados

 

[Mabearette]

The one last week at Tynecastle , even Chris Sutton was embarrassed with the award.

Shocking dive...bit of a habit with him

 

[Tommy48]

That wee Japanese runt needs his balls booted right up into his throat

With his dicky shoulder someone needs to do to him what Sergio Ramos did to Mo Salah in the WC.

 

[Albertz Loyal]

The one last week at Tynecastle , even Chris Sutton was embarrassed with the award.

Total joke.. And how can't var change that to a dive is beyond me

 

[unionjock2]

Doesn't help that Rangers fans help encourage it with the 'Penalty to Rangers' patter.

It annoys the %^*& out of them so all good for me

 

[DEJABLUE62]

Total joke.. And how can't var change that to a dive is beyond me

It's a scandalous decision

 

[DezzaS]

The one last week at Tynecastle , even Chris Sutton was embarrassed with the award.

Jesus wept. Ive never seen that.

Another example of the Bheasts having absolutely zero self awareness.

 

[newblue]

Jesus wept. Ive never seen that.

Another example of the Bheasts having absolutely zero self awareness.

For the most part it's not a self-awareness problem, it's much more insidious than that.

I'd say most of them know the score but they try to control the narrative and make them out to be victims all the time in the hope that the media follows and puts pressure on officials.

I mean, I remember a while back even BBC Scotland laughing about us and the Tavpen thing. That comes directly from their fans.

The dumb fucks in their support will think they're genuinely being treated unfairly but the others know exactly what they're doing and it works.

 

[Usabear]

They have raged for years at Beaton for being a Masonic ref I guess they will appeal to have it rejected now so they can sleep better

 

[MrStruth]

The mhedia already in full deflection mode.

https://twitter.com/x/status/1720136796242169964

 

[Bobby Russell]

Doesn't help that Rangers fans help encourage it with the 'Penalty to Rangers' patter.

Would it make a difference if they stopped it?

 

[captcaveman]

Something you won’t read about on KDS.
Last nights commentary on Sportscene.
To be honest, I didn’t expect to hear it there either!

I did put this up the other week on here

'Penalty to Rangers' catchphrase challenged by Celtic as spot kick table revealed

THE phrase ‘Penalty to Rangers’ has passed into the vocabulary of Scottish football in recent seasons. So frequently has James Tavernier stuck the ball away from 12 yards that even the …

www.thescottishsun.co.uk

 

[tazzabear]

I did put this up the other week on here

'Penalty to Rangers' catchphrase challenged by Celtic as spot kick table revealed

THE phrase ‘Penalty to Rangers’ has passed into the vocabulary of Scottish football in recent seasons. So frequently has James Tavernier stuck the ball away from 12 yards that even the …

www.thescottishsun.co.uk

Great information.
Unfortunately, it’s no use to the Sellik support as it is factual.

 

[tazzabear]

The mhedia already in full deflection mode.

https://twitter.com/x/status/1720136796242169964

KDS “Oh look, found one.
Proves that the red are against us.”
That said, you can't tell from a still.

 

[tazzabear]

That is pathetic. Pathetic the ref gave it, pathetic that VAR didn't overturn & pathetic that wee bowl cutted, tranny looking little weirdo took a dive in the first place.

All the handball pens that are given do my head in as well. No penalty claim that hits someone's hand should be decided by VAR. All handball's will look like pens slowed down 4-5 times on camera.

Highly ridiculous line.
If you cheat the best, you win.
Madness.

 

[captcaveman]

Great information.
Unfortunately, it’s no use to the Sellik support as it is factual.

I know, Ive posted in online & posted these

season 22/23
we tied with hearts but they scored more

Scottish Premiership - Penalties received

Diese Statistik der Scottish Premiership gibt Aufschluss, welcher Verein die meisten Elfmeter in der 22/23 erhalten hat und es wird zusätzlich die Erfolgsquote angezeigt.

www.transfermarkt.co.uk

season 21/22
Ross county topped the penalties that yr

Scottish Premiership - Penalties received

Diese Statistik der Scottish Premiership gibt Aufschluss, welcher Verein die meisten Elfmeter in der 22/23 erhalten hat und es wird zusätzlich die Erfolgsquote angezeigt.

www.transfermarkt.co.uk

 

[Flying Fullback]

Extremely interesting that a player “planting his foot to impede an opponent” can now get a foul awarded for it if he gets contact from behind in the process.

Who knew?

That rule book interpretation didn’t take long to get backtracked, did it?

Celtic have won 2 penalties this season where I've thought it looked to me like it should have been freekicks against them for obstruction

 

[tazzabear]

I did put this up the other week on here

'Penalty to Rangers' catchphrase challenged by Celtic as spot kick table revealed

THE phrase ‘Penalty to Rangers’ has passed into the vocabulary of Scottish football in recent seasons. So frequently has James Tavernier stuck the ball away from 12 yards that even the …

www.thescottishsun.co.uk

Do they still hold the record for penalties in a season?
UK record it was too, at least for a while.

 

[staunchy]

classic deflection tactics from the mhanky mob, get and take everything that’s going but at the same time spouting pish about Masonic referees etc

 

[ElCamino]

The mhedia already in full deflection mode.

https://twitter.com/x/status/1720136796242169964

I hope he's ok after that high impact collision.

 

[Blue and True.]

Great information.
Unfortunately, it’s no use to the Sellik support as it is factual.

It is factual and they will reply we not conceded a penalty in 65 games.

 

[Angrybluebear]

Hearts have not had a penalty in the league this season despite having 18, which was more than anyone, over the 2 previous seasons.

Maybe that is why Shanklands goal tally this season is way down.

Anyone questioning why we haven’t conceded a penalty in the league should provide the average time and touches the opposition have in our box,

Maybe if we introduce VAR it will discover all these penalties referees have been ignoring, or maybe to the contrary it will eliminate the penalties given that shouldn’t have been.

 

[Apple Shampoo]

Has this not actually been the case most seasons despite them continually moaning about it?

 

[TheDerryend]

After seeing that Record post on x last night, there really is no point any more. To mention celtic fans in a game between Rangers and Hearts, tells you everything about what's going on.

 

[Clarence]

Watch every decision getting even more scrutinised if we cut the gap at all

When, not if.

 

[MartinS93]

Except, it's not.!
Too often we've been denied stonewallers due to the 'Penalty to Rangers' patter and a Ref not wishing to be seen "giving Rangers another penalty".. No matter how strong an appeal it is.

Nonsense.

 

[muttley]

The media propagandises the penalty to Rangers craziness, even when they have the stats sitting in front of them of other clubs being awarded more. The braindead fans of diddie clubs like Celtc, Hibs, Hearts, etc, just lap it up.

 

[Sticky]

The one last week at Tynecastle , even Chris Sutton was embarrassed with the award.

That is f'n shocking! Naismith must have been going radio!!!

 

[Sticky]

It's a soft penalty but soon as that's given it's not getting overturned when replays show contact made with the left knee.

Where do you class our penalty with St Mirren then you not want that given for handball?

The wee twunt is falling down BEFORE any contact!

 

[Angrybluebear]

Nonsense.

The media propagandises the penalty to Rangers craziness, even when they have the stats sitting in front of them of other clubs being awarded more. The braindead fans of diddie clubs like Celtc, Hibs, Hearts, etc, just lap it up.

3 of our last 5 penalties in domestic football have not initially been given by the referee.

When was the last penalty Kevin Clancy has given us in real time ? The last two he has given were awarded by VAR, both clear as day at the time too, Dundee last midweek and St Mirren away in GvB last game when his natural hardwired thinking was booking for Kent.

How many penalties have we had reversed by VAR ?

Off the top of my head celtic had 3 in the first 6 months of VAR, at Tannadice by Don Robertson, when the goalkeeper punched the ball, at St Mirren Park by David Dickinson when the foul was outside the box and another at the piggery by Steven McLean when Abada dived.

I should maybe bump this thread

Celtic have conceded the same amount of penalties this season as last 2 combined

Celtic have conceded the same amount of penalties this season so far as last 2 combined with the introduction of VAR. Off the top of my head they have also been awarded penalties VAR overturned; at Tannadice by Don Robertson, when the goalkeeper punched the ball, at St Mirren Park by David...

www.followfollow.com

 

[Dakota]

They don't like facts