According to VAR Review Panel, we’ve had the most decisions incorrectly go against us of any club in the league

[Brick_Top]

Incorrect VAR decisions against for the season according to the IRP:

Rangers 5
St Mirren 4
Dundee 4
Hearts 4
Hibs 2
Livingston 2
Aberdeen 2
St Johnstone 1
Motherwell 1
Celtic 1
Kilmarnock 0
Ross County 0

Interesting statistics considering all VAR does is apparently cheat in our favour and against the filth.

It’s nothing that most of our support don’t already know when it comes to being robbed by officials, but it just goes to show that the filths control over the narrative sways the rest of Scottish footballs opinions to somehow think all the officials work in our favour.

The reality is massively different.

 

[MartinS93]

Just confirming what we all knew.

Was probably the sane last year as well.

 

[gsobers96]

Worst referee conspiracy ever

 

[RabSpackman]

Incorrect VAR decisions against for the season according to the IRP:

Rangers 5
St Mirren 4
Dundee 4
Hearts 4
Hibs 2
Livingston 2
Aberdeen 2
Kilmarnock 2
St Johnstone 1
Motherwell 1
Celtic 1
Ross County 0

Interesting statistics considering all VAR does is apparently cheat in our favour and against the filth.

The only decision they’ve had incorrectly called against them was a penalty in a game in which they also incorrectly got awarded a penalty.

It’s nothing that most of our support don’t already know when it comes to being robbed by officials, but it just goes to show that the filths control over the narrative sways the rest of Scottish footballs opinions to somehow think all the officials work in our favour.

The reality is massively different.

Even with these statistics being released by the people in control of VAR, you will still find Celtic’s representatives in the media banging the drum that they are hard done to through it.

 

[hhss]

Have we not had something like 10 penalties given after VAR review on their own?

I assume this is for ones that we didn’t get or were wrongly given against us.

 

[gsobers96]

Also both us and Dundee had a red card that was given on the pitch, sent to the monitor by VAR, then confirmed by the ref, appealed by the club, then confirmed again by the SFA. These were determined to be incorrect decisions by the review.

 

[RabSpackman]

Worst referee conspiracy ever

A conspiracy that has been going since the 60s apparently, and has limited Celtic to winning approximately only half of the league titles that have been played for in that 60yr period.

Like you say, as conspiracies go it has been utterly ineffective.

 

[muttley]

Patterns of assistance.

 

[jaws73]

No surprise we've topped this particular League Table.

 

[tazzabear]

Incorrect VAR decisions against for the season according to the IRP:

Rangers 5
St Mirren 4
Dundee 4
Hearts 4
Hibs 2
Livingston 2
Aberdeen 2
Kilmarnock 2
St Johnstone 1
Motherwell 1
Celtic 1
Ross County 0

Interesting statistics considering all VAR does is apparently cheat in our favour and against the filth.

It’s nothing that most of our support don’t already know when it comes to being robbed by officials, but it just goes to show that the filths control over the narrative sways the rest of Scottish footballs opinions to somehow think all the officials work in our favour.

The reality is massively different.

VAR personnel taking no chances when making sure it’s the RC who get the most benefit!

 

[Mexi]

And then there is the fouls committed per game stat. For a club that's cheated at every turn, they seem to get the rub of the green every time

 

[gsobers96]

And then there is the fouls committed per game stat. For a club that's cheated at every turn, they seem to get the rub of the green every time

Best stat to look at to see a ref’s performance in a game imo is the fouls to booking ratio for each team. Guess which team almost always comes out miles ahead.

 

[Trafalgar]

Also both us and Dundee had a red card that was given on the pitch, sent to the monitor by VAR, then confirmed by the ref, appealed by the club, then confirmed again by the SFA. These were determined to be incorrect decisions by the review.

Those responsibile at both the game and the review panel should be sacked for incompetence

 

[TerryMunro]

Yet the only time SFA has intervened is when they needed to coverup a blatant penalty by drawing their own lines to engineer an offside.
Scottish football is corrupted! The macolin convention is designed to hold match fixing to account and the SFA with their in-house football team has easily reached the criteria for such involvement.

 

[Kb91]

For as bad as we’ve been and as much as we’ve thrown it away , we’ve been shafted time and time again. If VAR had been applied correctly we’d be top of this league still.

 

[muttley]

And then there is the fouls committed per game stat. For a club that's cheated at every turn, they seem to get the rub of the green every time

Least penalties against them, least red cards against them. But Masonic refs, etc.

 

[gsobers96]

Those responsibile at both the game and the review panel should be sacked for incompetence

No surprise it was Don Robertson for Sterling’s red

 

[Shengus Malengus]

Best stat to look at to see a ref’s performance in a game imo is the fouls to booking ratio for each team. Guess which team almost always comes out miles ahead.

Season after season.
Oh! And next season too.

But it's just a coincidence.

 

[gsobers96]

Season after season.
Oh! And next season too.

But it's just a coincidence.

These things even out over time…

 

[Grimsdale]

Wonder how many of the wrong decisions against other teams involved Celt*c ?

 

[HMS.Temple.Garden]

Vatican Assisted Referees indeed

 

[McQueen]

Incorrect VAR decisions against for the season according to the IRP:

Rangers 5
St Mirren 4
Dundee 4
Hearts 4
Hibs 2
Livingston 2
Aberdeen 2
Kilmarnock 2
St Johnstone 1
Motherwell 1
Celtic 1
Ross County 0

Interesting statistics considering all VAR does is apparently cheat in our favour and against the filth.

It’s nothing that most of our support don’t already know when it comes to being robbed by officials, but it just goes to show that the filths control over the narrative sways the rest of Scottish footballs opinions to somehow think all the officials work in our favour.

The reality is massively different.

This is how many have incorrectly gone against each team. Any indication of how many have gone incorrectly for each team?

I’d bet the table is reversed.

 

[muttley]

A week of discussion on this disparity in the media and phone-ins.? Nah, don't think so.

 

[deedle]

The crux of the matter is that despite the number of posts on here defending referees, the stats tell a different story.

It's not just VAR mistakes, it's the high proportion of our penalties referred to VAR and the abnormally low yellow cards/foul stat Celtic continually notch up season after season.

 

[gsobers96]

This is how many have incorrectly gone against each team. Any indication of how many have gone incorrectly for each team?

I’d bet the table is reversed.

https://twitter.com/x/status/1785680385570939264

 

[WinkieWATP]

What a surprise that isn’t.

Add that to blatant penalties like at McDermaid park not being given without the aid of VAR.

 

[weetam3106]

Wait. Are you sure those stats are correct. I only heard in passing but I’m fairly sure on Celtics radio station radio clyde that Gordon Duncan proclaimed that st mirren were the club most hard done by? Did anyone else pick up on this or am I mistaken?

 

[Class of 72]

Incorrect VAR decisions against for the season according to the IRP:

Rangers 5
St Mirren 4
Dundee 4
Hearts 4
Hibs 2
Livingston 2
Aberdeen 2
Kilmarnock 2
St Johnstone 1
Motherwell 1
Celtic 1
Ross County 0

Interesting statistics considering all VAR does is apparently cheat in our favour and against the filth.

It’s nothing that most of our support don’t already know when it comes to being robbed by officials, but it just goes to show that the filths control over the narrative sways the rest of Scottish footballs opinions to somehow think all the officials work in our favour.

The reality is massively different.

Interestingly when we were doing shite we had none but from October onwards we’ve had 5. Makes you think eh?

 

[gsobers96]

Wait. Are you sure those stats are correct. I only heard in passing but I’m fairly sure on Celtics radio station radio clyde that Gordon Duncan proclaimed that st mirren were the club most hard done by? Did anyone else pick up on this or am I mistaken?

They are when you do the differential between decisions benefitting and against. I posted the chart a few posts up.

 

[BrooklynBlue]

Is the Celtic decision in the game vs. Hearts?

If so, they got a penalty that wasn’t to negate the decision against them.

 

[DJT]

VAR (review panel) will sort it.

 

[sofakineazy]

Incorrect VAR decisions against for the season according to the IRP:

Rangers 5
St Mirren 4
Dundee 4
Hearts 4
Hibs 2
Livingston 2
Aberdeen 2
Kilmarnock 2
St Johnstone 1
Motherwell 1
Celtic 1
Ross County 0

Interesting statistics considering all VAR does is apparently cheat in our favour and against the filth.

It’s nothing that most of our support don’t already know when it comes to being robbed by officials, but it just goes to show that the filths control over the narrative sways the rest of Scottish footballs opinions to somehow think all the officials work in our favour.

The reality is massively different.

Pattern of assistance.

 

[McQueen]

Wait. Are you sure those stats are correct. I only heard in passing but I’m fairly sure on Celtics radio station radio clyde that Gordon Duncan proclaimed that st mirren were the club most hard done by? Did anyone else pick up on this or am I mistaken?

That will be the differential. The number incorrectly for minus the number incorrectly against.

 

[Grumpy Old Git]

Yet we still have some on here who go into defensive mode on behalf of referees/var and their decisions in OF games.

 

[FDB1978]

Said it before but until someone from Rangers comes out and challenges the narrative Celtic pump out absolutely nothing will change.

Four disallowed goals against them in the last five league games and we've said absolutely nothing about it.

We all know what’s coming in the next few weeks a constant stream of propaganda and Rangers getting shafted in one or both games against them.

 

[Blootoonboy]

You will see this reported in a total of 0 newspapers here!

 

[geedee]

VAR was wrong to send Sterling off.
So what about appeal board who upheld decision?
Couldn’t make it up.

 

[Del]

Definite pattern of assistance here.

 

[G74Bear]

I’ve seen so many different stats of this today

 

[sg9375]

And I have a horrible feeling these honest mistakes and disgraceful VAR decisions will be occuring more than ever in the next 3 weeks.

 

[Flying_Scotsman]

Worst referee conspiracy ever

Is it a conspiracy!! A conspiracy is usually done in secret and isn't blatantly obvious. The latter and the former don't apply to our decisions.

 

[muttley]

Yet we still have some on here who go into defensive mode on behalf of referees/var and their decisions in OF games.

Even when repeatedly presented with irrefutable proof of the loaded dice we are up against, season after season, some just think that refs and officials are " incompetent. "

 

[VelvetOrange]

No surprise there. And even before VAR we were the team most wronged i expect.
The thing that strikes me is what the hell is this actually telling us - is it that our officials are so incapable of making correct decisions , even with tech to help them?
IF this is meaningful data, with a purpose, then surely the next action would be for those VAR experts/refs to declare why the are making wrong decisions.

 

[The Moon on Mars is Blue]

It's interesting the amount of penalties we have been given after a VAR review that were not given by the referee at the time. If it wasn't for VAR we would be nowhere near competing for the league. Says all about the refs.

 

[Boabski Bluenose]

Any idea what difference this would have made to points between them and us?

 

[Battle Fever's On]

Some of the comments on that thread are mental, even when presented with facts they are still trying to imply that we are favoured by refs and VAR.

 

[Brick_Top]

Is the Celtic decision in the game vs. Hearts?

If so, they got a penalty that wasn’t to negate the decision against them.

Correct.

Both penalties were incorrect according to the VAR independent review.

 

[Brick_Top]

A week of discussion on this disparity in the media and phone-ins.? Nah, don't think so.

Nah all is well in the world again now that the filth are back top.

All the chatter about officials literally disappeared the day Ross County beat us.

 

[Bknowe]

The crux of the matter is that despite the number of posts on here defending referees, the stats tell a different story.

It's not just VAR mistakes, it's the high proportion of our penalties referred to VAR and the abnormally low yellow cards/foul stat Celtic continually notch up season after season.

'But, but, but wur just as bad as them for being paranoid'

FF referee loyal

 

[CambridgeRanger]

Careful now, showing clear evidence of things going against us this season may break the Hate Crime Act