Beaton - compare and contrast

[bleau]

I may be wrong , I thought the player had to be facing / looking at ref when being carded ? If so it looks like the 2nd card was waved in the managers direction when his back was turned
Personally Rangers should ask that these @ officials “ do not officiate at any more Rangers games I’m sure a couple of EPL clubs have done this

 

[Disco Deejay]

He was miles behind play last night, so I can accept that he never had a clear view that it was a penalty.

He had 3 choices:

Penalty - Correct decision.

No action - Wrong decision. People would have been annoyed, but most would have accepted it.

Yellow Card for simulation - Wrong decision x 2. If he never had a clear view that it was a penalty, then he obviously never had a clear view that it was simulation and he produced a Yellow Card purely on Alfie's mhedia driven reputation.

 

[Bermondsey Wall West]

Correct me if I am wrong but did he not book McGregor for time wasting when Livingston were making a substitution?

That was my take as well, thought my telly was out of sync.

 

[Valleyloyal]

As SG said, he can understand one official getting it wrong, but all three, when the Livj manager, all the TV pundits and all viewers could see it? That's more tha a simple error.

Even Andy Walker said it was a stonewall penalty, Did any one else think Sky must have had a few words with Crocker and Walker? Commentary last night was almost decent.

 

[cooperman]

we should get refs from other countries, then again, some of them are mince too judging by our last europa league game

 

[Brant Hurley]

John Beaton learned early that penalising RFC had no adverse consequences for his lucrative part-time job. But last night revealed an ugly, egotistic personality trait.

 

[Bouncyboy]

That was my take as well, thought my telly was out of sync.

It was us making the substitution, Zungu was coming on. I couldn't understand how he could book him for time wasting when the game was already stopped

 

[blue barney]

John Beaton learned early that penalising RFC had no adverse consequences for his lucrative part-time job. But last night revealed an ugly, egotistic personality trait.

I wonder if he will apologise for not giving us the penalty, just like the way he crawled up Brendan Rogers arse.

 

[Blueranger45]

Itten should have had a penalty late on as well when he had his jersey pulled, however we didn't get the pen and Itten wasn't booked for diving (which he didn't anyway)

just shows the reputation for Morelos is based on the media, not the player

 

[gorams_glayva]

And having a mentally challenged loving linesman helped him come to the decision.

Who was the nearside linesman last night?

 

[SpectraBear]

Correct me if I am wrong but did he not book McGregor for time wasting when Livingston were making a substitution?

Said this last last night.. never known that to be possible

 

[SSR]

The worst referring performance I have ever seen, Hibs at Ibrox, was beyond comprehension.

Should have never Refereed another game after that!!

 

[Bknowe]

I agree, but Kilmarnock away last season ran it close. Im not sure who the ref was that day but he was giving decisions on nothing more than guess work and robbed us of 3 points in what was then a pretty close title race.

Beaton was the ref that day too.

 

[ShotaShuffle]

This goes back to our first season back in tbe top flight.

Rangers Hibs at Ibrox.

Morelos through on goal, Darren Mcgregor rugby tackles Alfie, in mid air two arms around his waist. Pulls down Morelos preventing a clear goal scoring opportunity. Red card and free kick to Rangers.

What does Beaton see? A fould against McGregor.

This cheating bastard needs hounded out

 

[buc11]

He pulls some amount of smug and bizarre faces as well.

 

[seturdaysanny]

The worst referring performance I have ever seen, Hibs at Ibrox, was beyond comprehension.

I have left Ibrox moaning about a few refs over the years but that day was the first
time I left convinced we had been deliberately cheated.

 

[Slayer]

No neck Beaton and his like continue to ruin football. Protected, unaccountable, arrogant, discourteous and contemptuous. They must be the centre of attention. SG deserved huge credit for keeping his cool when confronted by that.

 

[instructor]

Probably got a buzz out of sending off Gerrard. He's such a coward as well, not sending off the Aberdeen player against us recently as he'd already sent one of them off.

 

[exiled_bear]

Cheatin Beaton should be sacked. I can't remember a more incompetent official than him.

 

[Barca Bear]

Didn’t he apologise to Rodgers at half time on one occasion- for not awarding a penalty?

Tynecastle
ps, it might have been during the h/t break.

 

[From1872]

Tynecastle
ps, it might have been during the h/t break.

I’m sure it was.

 

[archimedes]

Even Andy Walker said it was a stonewall penalty, Did any one else think Sky must have had a few words with Crocker and Walker? Commentary last night was almost decent.

This is a trick that Walker plays.

Whenever he knows that a decision has gone the wrong way against Rangers that would have benefitted us but now won't, he plays it up in order to sound like he is impartial.

When it is something he thinks we could be punished for he repeats it over and over in order to influence the narrative.