Great post by the op.
I was born in 77 and started going to Ibrox in 82, so can't really remember seeing DJ much. I knew of his stats but the way the op was set out, really told more of the story, so thanks for that.
You old yins
all go on about pre and post Argentina, like he went away in may as a scrawny lad and returned in August the size of a house. Was it really that bad? That quickly? I see plenty footage in early 80s and you can tell it's a losing battle, but for it to happen so fast, and to a 27yo seems mental.
By his own very high standards that he himself had set, yes, after 78' there was a decline.
By anyone else's standards he was not so bad at all, as most on here would have you believe.
In that summer of 78', Johnstone handed in a Transfer request, then later tore it up and was named as team Captain.
The 78-79 Season, John Greig's first season in charge, where Johnstone 'preferred' to play at centre back (and has subsequently been accused of lacking drive),
he still weighed in with 16 goals, which was only two less than top scorer Gordon Smith with 18 goals.
Rangers retained both the League Cup and Scottish Cup, and narrowly lost out on back to back Trebles.
He scored a last minute winner v St Mirren in the League Cup, as Rangers came from 0-2 down
to win 3-2, and Rangers went on to win the Trophy defeating Celtic in the Semi Final, and Aberdeen in the Final.
In the Scottish Cup, it was Derek Johnstone who dragged us to that Trophy, following that crushing defeat to Celtic in the League. It was Johnstone who scored the only goal of the game in the Semi Final replay v Partick Thistle, and again in the Scottish Cup Final it was two goals from Derek Johnstone, that finally saw us overcome Hibs 3-2 in the second replay (after two 0-0 draws).
In the European Cup, Johnstone starred in two of our most famous victories ever, in a 2-0 win v Juventus (9 of Italy's World Cup Squad), and he scored the second equaliser in the 3-2 win away to PSV Eindhoven (their first ever defeat on home soil in Europe).
So for a fat lazy bastard of a Centre Back, I think the Big Man did very well that season.
I cannot think of any Centre Back, anywhere, who had a return of 16 Goals in a Single season.
Rangers never recovered from that League defeat to Celtic in May 79'.
Even in John Greig's second season in charge (1979-80), where Rangers finished a disastrous 5th in the League, Derek Johnstone was far and away the top scorer with 21 Goals.
The closest to that was John McDonald and Bobby Russell with 8 Goals each.
The much loved Gordon Smith scored 7 goals in 47 games!
In Dec 79' Johnstone scored winning goals against Morton and Dundee Utd, in the League, which took his tally to 13 goals in 26 games (including 2 in Europe).
Jock Stein recalled Johnstone to the National team for European Qualifier against Belgium.
Before the month was out, he scored in the 1-1 draw with Celtic.
In the Scottish Cup, Johnstone scored an 86th min. winner against Dundee Utd in the Fourth Round, scored again in the 6-1 tanking of Hearts in the QF, then scored the winner against Champions in waiting, Aberdeen (who had already defeated us 5 times already that season) in the Semi Final.
Rangers cruelly lost the Final to Celtic in extra time to a deflected shot.
So that's two seasons where Johnstone is often severely criticised by many on here, but in my opinion, he was clearly our most significant player.
The only highlights of 80-81 was beating Celtic at the piggery with a last minute Alex Miller goal, and a 3-0 roasting v Celtic in November.
Johnstone did still collect another Scottish Cup Winners medal, when a Davie Cooper inspired performance saw us defeat Dundee Utd 4-1 in the Scottish Cup Final replay.
Six months later, Johnstone added another League Cup medal to his cabinet, when we defeated Dundee Utd again 2-1 in the League Cup Final.
Derek Johnstone is one of only two players who can lay claim to having played under Willie Waddell, Jock Wallace, John Greig and Walter Smith.