You forgetting you clarified that with
"It's not just an open and shut case of bomb him out. That will teach him and make him play better."?
Anyway, we have differing views on this and we're getting nowhere.
I think you misunderstood the "open and shut case" comment. I was saying that "just bombing him out because that will teach him" seems to be the only way people seem to think his mistakes can and should be dealt with. It is blatantly not my opinion.
But aye, getting nowhere.