Keeper getting treatment off the park - what's the rule?

[gers1978]

Seeing the St Johnstone keeper getting treatment off the pitch there got me curious - what's the actual rule? Seems to me it should be play on with 10 men, as it would be if an outfield player was being treated off field; is it actually a different rule for keepers or is it just refs applying common sense?

 

[Portals_Bear_Blue]

Can’t believe this is even a question

 

[Dado's Bandage]

Shut up.

 

[a_weir]

Of course they’re not going to let play continue with out a GK ffs.

 

[Marc]

Is this the same person that asked what score do we need on Weds to qualify‍???

surely people that watch football have some idea of the rules

 

[Ianis 4 the 55]

Just wow

 

[WinkieWATP]

Come on tae %^*&

 

[Unicorn]

One of the more desperate ref scapegoating threads

 

[Gibraltar Loyal]

Seeing the St Johnstone keeper getting treatment off the pitch there got me curious - what's the actual rule? Seems to me it should be play on with 10 men, as it would be if an outfield player was being treated off field; is it actually a different rule for keepers or is it just refs applying common sense?

Certainly no common sense in your post

 

[gers1978]

Not blaming anyone or anything for anything - forget the result, even the teams involved. In fact I posted this when we were 2-1 up did I not? Simply curious as to what's the actual rule for a player (let's say outfield or keeper) being off the field getting treatment. Is it ref's discretion?

 

[Barca Bear]

How did this question get past admin,
or brains trust.

 

[gers1978]

Is this the same person that asked what score do we need on Weds to qualify‍♂???

surely people that watch football have some idea of the rules

Ok, tell me what the rule is, that's all I'm wondering.

 

[WinkieWATP]

Ok, tell me what the rule is, that's all I'm wondering.

You can’t expect a team to play with no goalkeeper?

 

[TerrySilverLoyal]

They are supposed to pull a fan in to keep edgy on the 6 yard box

 

[Mr. Blue]

Play stops.

 

[gers1978]

You can’t expect a team to play with no goalkeeper?

Of course not. But for no other reason than curiosity, I'm wondering if there's an actual written rule on it, or if it's left to ref's discretion to apply common sense. For some reason that seems to have got the teeth nashers out in force. I'm guessing from the replies so far that no one knows.

 

[Mr. Blue]

Play stops.

End thread.

 

[Installer]

Last man keeper, no hands.

 

[Marc]

Of course not. But for no other reason than curiosity, I'm wondering if there's an actual written rule on it, or if it's left to ref's discretion to apply common sense. For some reason that seems to have got the teeth nashers out in force. I'm guessing from the replies so far that no one knows.

Written rule...
Can’t play without a designated goalkeeper
Apologies for the teeth nashing

 

[LittleGer]

That's a question for Google not The Bear Pit.

 

[gers1978]

That's a question for Google not The Bear Pit.

Is it aye? Do you have a list of the things we are and aren't allowed to ask?

 

[PrivateAye72]

Is this the same person that asked what score do we need on Weds to qualify‍♂???

surely people that watch football have some idea of the rules

Same folk calling for offside at the Killie game... from a goal kick.

 

[nybear]

only the keeper can stop the ball with his hands so game stops any other player going off for treatment another member the team can play there if needed till he comes back on or substituted, most diddy teams play with ten defenders in the box.

 

[CupGoalie]

Same folk calling for offside at the Killie game... from a goal kick.

Two different folk around me recently have screamed offside at a throw in. Utterly baffling.

 

[Craigie]

Not blaming anyone or anything for anything - forget the result, even the teams involved. In fact I posted this when we were 2-1 up did I not? Simply curious as to what's the actual rule for a player (let's say outfield or keeper) being off the field getting treatment. Is it ref's discretion?

Play stops as there must be a designated goalkeeper on the field of play at all times.

Can't believe someone actually asks this type of thing.

 

[Craigie]

That's a question for Google not The Bear Pit.

In fairness if everyone uses google this place would die on it's arse.

Asking questions, granted some are better than others, sparks debate on here.

 

[347golfer]

If he goes off the park then it's 'any man save' but if he comes back on then hes a 'scorey backy'

 

[sheddensbear]

Obviously played rounders at school.

 

[Portrushbear]

No shots from your own half and last man back is the keeper

Fuckin collum the cheating prick

 

[The Tartan Bear]

It's play on but you can only shoot from your own half

 

[Ulsterbear]

If its Rangers its game on and shoot from anywhere. Any other team they wait til the keepers ok to continue

 

[Mondraker]

Is this the same person that asked what score do we need on Weds to qualify‍♂???

surely people that watch football have some idea of the rules

Why? The fucking refs dont or should that be

 

[TN8]

Please file this thread beside "what result do we need in Braga" in the folder marked Mongo.

 

[Rosscoger]

Any man save. Surely everyone knows that.

 

[clubdeckcharlie]

Lazy or what?

Let Me Google That

For all those people that find it more convenient to bother you with their question than to google it for themselves.

letmegooglethat.com

 

[WestEndGer18]

Seeing the St Johnstone keeper getting treatment off the pitch there got me curious - what's the actual rule? Seems to me it should be play on with 10 men, as it would be if an outfield player was being treated off field; is it actually a different rule for keepers or is it just refs applying common sense?

Are you a Kevin Clancy?

 

[LittleGer]

Is it aye? Do you have a list of the things we are and aren't allowed to ask?

Sure admin have rules.
Poor bloke has been ripped into for asking his question though

 

[Spudgun]

OP question possibly not as daft as it looks?

What is the rule in football which needs the play to be stopped whenever the goalkeeper is injured? How did it prevent the GK from faking...

Answer (1 of 2): There is not a specific “rule” within Laws of the Game (rules of football) giving this preference to goalkeepers. The one specific “codified” rule in this regard is that goalkeepers can be treated for injury and not have to leave the game (while other players are generally requir...

www.quora.com

 

[PunkScott]

In the stars now, McGregor will need treatment one week and the referee will ask an outfield player to go in until he's ready

 

[GF7]

OP question possibly not as daft as it looks?

What is the rule in football which needs the play to be stopped whenever the goalkeeper is injured? How did it prevent the GK from faking...

Answer (1 of 2): There is not a specific “rule” within Laws of the Game (rules of football) giving this preference to goalkeepers. The one specific “codified” rule in this regard is that goalkeepers can be treated for injury and not have to leave the game (while other players are generally requir...

www.quora.com

Nah it really is just a daft question

 

[ottawabear]

You don't want to know what happens when two teammates are getting medical treatment at the same time!

 

[Spudgun]

You don't want to know what happens when two teammates are getting medical treatment at the same time!

Happened already at Ibrox this season, two defenders injured going for same ball and both treated on park, neither had to leave field of play.

As far as I recall, it was a correct response.

 

[ottawabear]

Happened already at Ibrox this season, two defenders injured going for same ball and both treated on park, neither had to leave field of play.

As far as I recall, it was a correct response.

BUT if only one of them is a serious injury needing treatment, the other just looked at as OK then the treated player has to go off, the other can stay on.

 

[Chopper]

edit. Bad joke.

 

[Graemeh89]

The rule to leave the park for treatment and continue the game doesn’t apply to goalkeepers. Thought that would be obvious to anyone with half a brain