When Halliday got robbed and the boy scored

[Live Forever]

Was it a foul? Couldn’t see too clearly from Copland but it looked like Halliday was a bit too casual and not that much in it.

Thought he got away with 1 there.

 

[StaunchEnclosure]

He had loads of time and was far too casual. I think it would be harsh if that happened at the other end

 

[Geez it]

Going by collums rule of “any contacts a foul” then yes. Absolute worst c*nt of a ref.

 

[RWL12]

Going by collums rule of “any contacts a foul” then yes. Absolute worst c*nt of a ref.

Surprised Collumn wasnt up waiting to tap it in

 

[Bearsden Bear]

Was it a foul? Couldn’t see too clearly from Copland but it looked like Halliday was a bit too casual and not that much in it.

Thought he got away with 1 there.

Yes.

 

[GEODGC]

We got away with one. I thought the decision was very soft.

 

[Peter Venkman]

Thought we were very lucky if I’m honest

 

[Chester Loyal]

If I’m being honest I thought it was a terrible decision from the ref but I’m delighted he made it.

I didn’t think it was a foul and I think we got away with one today.

As much as people slate Collum, I actually think he’s probably the “fairest” ref we get.

 

[RandyMac]

Going by collums rule of “any contacts a foul” then yes. Absolute worst c*nt of a ref.

This. But any normal ref it’s not a foul and Andy’s got away with a howler. Far too casual.

 

[Ally’s Golden Boot]

He was garbage today. Never a left back in a million years. No idea why Barasic wasn’t playing.

PS to answer your question he got away with one. He made a right c()nt if it and the ref saved him.

 

[LD5]

Halliday is rotten, hopefully Barisic just wasn't played to give him a rest after the 2 Croatia games.

 

[Coza]

It was an obvious foul. I thought given officials are terrified to give us anything we were however lucky to get it.

 

[SDF]

Halliday got extremely lucky I thought. Forget the foul, him dallying on the ball is the same sort of basic mistake he was making three years ago under Warburton.

He doesn't fanny about and we're not even discussing this.

 

[LiborSionko14]

Halliday got lucky.
Should have dealt with it first time. If that happened against us we’d be raging.

 

[Blackpool Dave]

Halliday should have kicked it out of the park

 

[Forza_Napoli]

Wasn't a foul if that's at the other end and collum disallowed it we would be fuming

 

[BeakerB]

We got a break from Collum, only one of game. Never a foul , Halliday was muscled out of it due too his pissing about!

 

[weevlad]

Aye was a very very soft foul on Halliday

We were lucky

 

[drgriffen]

It was soft but probably a foul. Halliday was really poor, though. Should have handled the situation far better.

I will add, if it had been the other way round I would have been complaining if a foul had been given.

 

[Gazzaflag]

I thought it was very soft. Halliday was very poor again today, dithered on the ball far too often.

 

[Live Forever]

Halliday got extremely lucky I thought. Forget the foul, him dallying on the ball is the same sort of basic mistake he was making three years ago under Warburton.

He doesn't fanny about and we're not even discussing this.

Yes. He had loads of time to deal with that ball. Far too sloppy.

 

[david1982]

Collum today was fucking chronic. Allowed a Livingston player being subbed to walk all the way over the pitch from the Govan instead of papping the c.unt off at the Govan side as you now can with the new rules. Gives the Livingston player a 2nd yellow for violent conduct instead of straight red?....

 

[Monts1310]

Looked harsh on Livi, from the Main Stand.

It is what it is.











55. NS.

 

[Paperskin]

Was it a foul? Couldn’t see too clearly from Copland but it looked like Halliday was a bit too casual and not that much in it.

Thought he got away with 1 there.

Looked extremely fortunate to me and very lucky considering Gollums antics today

 

[Brian Laudrup]

If it had been the other way around we would have been going mental

 

[CaptainCourageous]

Halliday got extremely lucky I thought. Forget the foul, him dallying on the ball is the same sort of basic mistake he was making three years ago under Warburton.

He doesn't fanny about and we're not even discussing this.

He shouldn't be getting picked then we wouldn't have to be discussing how poor he is.

East Fife was the final straw, he's garbage.

 

[The Royal Standard]

Halliday got lucky, very lucky .
Amateur defending

 

[mkgers]

Don't know why Halliday let it bounce once let alone twice.

 

[possil bear]

it was a foul

 

[Oshahoorsir]

Lucky to get away with it I thought.

Defending 101 - don’t let the ball bounce.

 

[PalefaceRedskin]

Was it a foul? Couldn’t see too clearly from Copland but it looked like Halliday was a bit too casual and not that much in it.

Thought he got away with 1 there.

It was a blatant foul mate.

 

[RainMan1972]

I’m in GR3 and to be honest it never looked like a foul, looked like Halliday got off with one. Did McGregor need to come out like that?

Will need to see it again mind you to be 100% sure.

 

[Blue As]

It was a foul,Collum gave them about half a dozen fouls for less.

 

[RainMan1972]

Looked extremely fortunate to me and very lucky considering Gollums antics today

Today it seemed utterly blatant the officials were out to get us. Very very clear in my opinion.

 

[Virgil Hilts]

Going by collums rule of “any contacts a foul” then yes. Absolute worst c*nt of a ref.

He’s a good cheat.

 

[Gheorghe_Hagi]

Just as an aside - McGregor needs to stop having those mental blood rushes when he charges out to the striker. They never come off for him and he'd have been just as culpable if it'd cost us.

 

[nelster]

The foul was in keeping with Collums afternoon

Contact = Foul

Even if it wasnt

 

[sheddensbear]

He played for the foul. He didn't know what to do, but he knew Columb would blow on contact, so stopped and guy barely touched him.

 

[Sapien]

Collum today was fucking chronic. Allowed a Livingston player being subbed to walk all the way over the pitch from the Govan instead of papping the c.unt off at the Govan side as you now can with the new rules. Gives the Livingston player a 2nd yellow for violent conduct instead of straight red?....

He seemed to indicate that he didn't want the player walking around the pitch in front of the fans. Basically means that the new rule won't apply at Ibrox.

 

[Live Forever]

He seemed to indicate that he didn't want the player walking around the pitch in front of the fans. Basically means that the new rule won't apply at Ibrox.

That’s only meant to kick in for high profile games with security risk.

 

[ricksen24]

Why’s Halliday still here in 2019. He’s never in a month of Sunday’s good enough.

Today (v Livi) proves that.

He got off the hook there the day

 

[Partickger]

I thought it was soft and really unexpected from Collum who was giving us nothing until then.

 

[Captain Black]

I had a very good view and if roles were reversed we would be going tonto

 

[bilkobear]

Maybe I have to watch it again but I thought the forward put his hands on Halliday's back. That is always a foul, soft but it is usually given.
That forward had a great game.

 

[Jonathan E]

It was a foul, just as their penalty was a penalty.

All this 'soft' pish is just a distraction from the facts.

 

[Monty_greenock34]

He seemed to indicate that he didn't want the player walking around the pitch in front of the fans. Basically means that the new rule won't apply at Ibrox.

I think he actually forgot the new rule then just made out about the walking round part, how can he not want players walking round while the livi subs warmed up infront of bf1 with no issue lol

 

[Buster]

Collum today was fucking chronic. Allowed a Livingston player being subbed to walk all the way over the pitch from the Govan instead of papping the c.unt off at the Govan side as you now can with the new rules. Gives the Livingston player a 2nd yellow for violent conduct instead of straight red?....

Seen that today mate as well , Tav lost the rag at him telling him he should have walked of at the Govan side which was only a couple of yards away , Referees decisions can be down to interpretation but in this case its a rule change ,the substituted player must leave by the nearest line . When Tav pointed it out he should have accepted his mistake and made the player turn around and leave by the Govan but he ignored Tav and let him meander of the long way
Mind you maybe they haven't changed that rule in the Rangers Rule Book for refs or maybe he was just cheating again

 

[jnloyal]

It was a push in the back although Halliday ought to have had it back to Greegs anyway and he certainly was causing unnecessary problems the way he went about defending it.

 

[Bordersbear]

Going by collums rule of “any contacts a foul” then yes. Absolute worst c*nt of a ref.

This all day long, some of the stuff he was blowing the whistle for was ludicrous.

Who referee's the game when he tells a players to exit the pitch at a substitution and the player just ignores him and walks off to the other side ?

 

[babaji]

Was it a foul? Couldn’t see too clearly from Copland but it looked like Halliday was a bit too casual and not that much in it.

Thought he got away with 1 there.

No