When Halliday got robbed and the boy scored

[Purpolaris]

Was it a foul? Couldn’t see too clearly from Copland but it looked like Halliday was a bit too casual and not that much in it.

Thought he got away with 1 there.

It's the sort of thing which happens to us week in, week out. I was surprised he gave it but it was a foul on Halliday. Did you see the foul he gave Livi for an Arfield tackle where he clearly won the ball. If that's a foul, I'm taking the one on Halliday all day. .

 

[Coda]

Just seen it there, 100% it's a foul.

Absolutely no chance. The contact was minimal, Halliday has got away with one big time, and to deny that doesn’t win any staunch points.

 

[Coda]

It’s folk who don’t like Halliday saying that’s not a foul.
A clear push on the back.

I like Halliday, still not a foul.

 

[bluebeak]

At the match I didn't think it was a foul but on reflection it must've been as it didn't merit a mention on BBC highlights.

 

[Captain Black]

Just watched the highlights.

If their penalty was a foul( which I think it was) then Halliday was also fouled. Both barged from the back and bowled over.
Halliday didn't "get away with one". He was fouled.
IMHO caveat

Just watched Sportscene. Seems I was wrong. I thought the pen was for Aribo's push on the Livy player. Didn't notice the Arfield trip. My bad.
Still a foul on Halliday, though

Chist I am drunk so Ian no quite what to say.

 

[JCDarcheville]

At the match I didn't think it was a foul but on reflection it must've been as it didn't merit a mention on BBC highlights.

Just came on to post the same thing.

 

[GF7]

Katic was horrendous yesterday,Goldson was the better of the 2 quite easily.

Agree Goldson covered a lot for Niko yesterday. They are both also offering a threat at set pieces though which I think people are underestimating; Goldson in particular this season seems to be on the end of a lot.

 

[Leif Erikson]

I like Halliday, still not a foul.

It was a 2 handed push in Halliday's back, how can that be anything other than a foul?

 

[Laudrup11Cooper]

Katic was horrendous yesterday. Strange to single out Goldson after that game.

Not sure if I got my point across but it’s all about the best partnership.
Not individuals.
Still think so far…Goldson and Katic is the best.

 

[tazzabear]

Katic was horrendous yesterday,Goldson was the better of the 2 quite easily.

Absolutely correct.
Katic gets a free ride on here for spme reason or another.
I don't have too much of a problem with this but, like with the press, I'd like a bit of balance and fairness.

 

[tazzabear]

I like Halliday, still not a foul.

Have you actually watched the incident?
It's as clear a foul as you can get.
100% no doubt aqbout it.
That said, Halliday's thinking and allowing there to be a challenge needs addressed.

 

[dt17]

Think it probably was a foul but Halliday's defending was atrocious.

Absolutely correct.
Katic gets a free ride on here for spme reason or another.
I don't have too much of a problem with this but, like with the press, I'd like a bit of balance and fairness.

Katic was definitely shaky the other day.

 

[Davieloyal]

Yes it was a foul if it happened at the other end they would have been screaming for a foul

 

[songsofglory]

Just watched the highlights.

If their penalty was a foul( which I think it was) then Halliday was also fouled. Both barged from the back and bowled over.
Halliday didn't "get away with one". He was fouled.
IMHO caveat

Just watched Sportscene. Seems I was wrong. I thought the pen was for Aribo's push on the Livy player. Didn't notice the Arfield trip. My bad.
Still a foul on Halliday, though

Eh? Their penalty was from a slide tackle.

 

[Blastie Bear]

That goal should of stood. We were very liucky

 

[CaptainCourageous]

Foul goes against us, we round the keeper and score, then every one on this thread and inside Ibrox are going off on one calling the referee a cheat. Guaranteed.

We got off with one, I'm just surprised Collum blew for a foul as he's a terrible referee.

 

[frankieboy]

Every time I see a post with Halliday’s name on it I know it’s going to be a witch-hunt.
We did it with Bob Malcolm,Charlie Adam and Stuart Munro too name just a few,our support seems to need a home whipping boy and by Christ we give them laldy.
I thought it was a foul and one of the few things that Colum got right.@