Have a look at this angle of Morelos disallowed goal

Partickger

Well-Known Member
Of course we’d have won, but the goal didn’t stand and that’s that. No point focusing in on an ambiguous moment when at that point in the game everyone watching knew what was coming.

We should have pummelled that lot 2, 3, 4 nil after going 1 up. That’s our problem right now, and that’s an aspect we can do something about. The referee agenda is clear, but there’s nothing we can do to change it/them.

The constant whining about decisions for days after we cock up isn’t doing us any favours though. Especially when Alfie tried to get soft decisions off Beaton all night.
so Alfue isn’t to get a decision all night then deserves to have a perfectly good goal chopped off just because?
I simply don’t believe that, if we’d scored a winner after being pegged back in the last 10 minutes the whole attitude to the side changes from everyone, even folk kidding on it wouldn’t!
Correct, all of a sudden the team has a bit of fight and just wait until we recapture our form. Like the 1st day of the season it would be all about character.

Instead we have idiots trying to defend a decision that was a mix of guesswork and cowardice.
 

davydumper

Well-Known Member
We should focus questions to our management team as to why they are not ripping Beaton a new one, if we can see what is happening then so should they, they have the platform to ask for answers whereas we don’t, the goal he disallowed is guesswork from Beaton as his view is partially obscured by players, and imo the goal should have stood, apart from that there was no foul and this why the club should seek an answer from Beaton as to why he has disallowed a perfectly good goal based on what he perceived as a push on the defender, remember the grief Collum got for awarding us a penalty against the scum where they claimed he must have had eyes in the back of his head to see that one.
 

mkgers

Well-Known Member
The goal should have stood. But we need to start winning games over the 90 minutes. Blaming referees every single week demeans us and achieves nothing.
This does my box in. If the perfectly good goal we scored was not disallowed and their handball goal was chopped off we would have won the game. The poor decisions cost us the game.

Yes we could've scored more but who's to say they'd have been allowed to stand with the quality of refereeing.

We should be able to win games by 1 goal, not have to score 5 in case the ref is so shit 3 are disallowed incorrectly.
 

Russell

Well-Known Member
I’ve got to add to this thread as I thought we were all being paranoid with decisions being made against us but after the game @ Piggery there’s definitely something up. It’s a miracle we won that game with what went on.

We are getting shafted...can someone tell me when we got a decision in a tight game in the last 18 months. Goldson’s hand ball Vrs Hamilton is the only one I can remember.

However I do think we are playing really poorly & although decisions are going against us I don’t think we deserved to win the game last night & I rewatched it today. We seem to lack the bite & will to win & it’s groundhog season again. Killie shaded it last night in my honest opinion...:mad:
 

Grigo Yossarian

Well-Known Member
I can't either. However, there is also the other issues that have intervened, such as losing our Captain in Dubai, Injuries to Ryan Jack and Jermaine Defoe, Alfie's ban, Davies missing games, introduction of Hagi and time to 'settle' into the team ... you could go on probably.

We had a fairly settled squad going into the game on the 29th Dec, but have had a good deal of disruption since then and that's not taking into consideration effect the media attacks on AM/negative media.

We have got 'cracks' as a previous poster suggested, but IMO the environment in the weeks since the OF at Parkhead has been poisonous to say the least.
Excellent & accurate post G57.
 

Oco1981

Active Member
I’m still not sure if the defender dived or just tried to twist his body. Not a foul in a million years though.
 

Laudrup's Right Foot

Well-Known Member
It’s infuriating but when our manager failed to call out Clancy, then Beaton at Pittodrie and then last night he even defended their first goal, what is the point?

We have a manager who is so naive it’s unreal. Imagine that went against the bheasts? Lennon would have went to town and rightly so.

Seems our manager is more interested in wanting to remain a good guy in the eyes of everyone, bit of McCoist about him
 

Grigo Yossarian

Well-Known Member
This does my box in. If the perfectly good goal we scored was not disallowed and their handball goal was chopped off we would have won the game. The poor decisions cost us the game.

Yes we could've scored more but who's to say they'd have been allowed to stand with the quality of refereeing.

We should be able to win games by 1 goal, not have to score 5 in case the ref is so shit 3 are disallowed incorrectly.
Let’s be honest MKG, if Dicker had gotten a very CLEAR second yellow, it could have had a significant impact on the scoreline too.

Alfie has had, rightly, a lot of stick for his dive but why is no one in the media talking about his pathetic attempt to cheat ?
 
Last edited:

RandyMac

Well-Known Member
If Beaton had gotten all his decisions correct I don’t think Morelos would’ve been on the park at the point of that goal as he’d have two yellows for two dives. Just like Gary Dicker should’ve been sent off. We lost because of another piss poor performance and I’m glad at least Gerrard has the balls to admit that.
 

allyscott

Well-Known Member
If Beaton had gotten all his decisions correct I don’t think Morelos would’ve been on the park at the point of that goal as he’d have two yellows for two dives. Just like Gary Dicker should’ve been sent off. We lost because of another piss poor performance and I’m glad at least Gerrard has the balls to admit that.
Burke would have been off as well. Against nine men we would have taken Alfie off to rest him.
 

mkgers

Well-Known Member
Let’s be honest MKG, if Dicker had gotten a very CLEAR second yellow, it could have had a significant impact on the shoreline too.

Alfie has had, rightly, a lot of stick for his dive but why is no one in the media talking about his pathetic attempt to cheat ?
I sea what you mean ;)

This is the same media who simultaneously denied and justified racist abuse of one of our players. Sadly the majority of them are quite happy with the current situation and the brutal thing is we as a club let them rip the piss on the daily.
 

Grigo Yossarian

Well-Known Member
I sea what you mean ;)

This is the same media who simultaneously denied and justified racist abuse of one of our players. Sadly the majority of them are quite happy with the current situation and the brutal thing is we as a club let them rip the piss on the daily.
We do mate. No bears seem to exist to fight our corner to put our views & justifications over.

It’s maddening.

And sorry for the typo:D:D
 

Tagsbear

Well-Known Member
You really think we’d be jumping for joy after just barely scraping by more SPL dross? We’d be clapping away in spite of the fact there’d still be no real sign of our getting back previous form where we didn’t toil week in week out......

I think there’s only one group kidding themselves and it ain’t the one I belong to. It’s either that or a simple case of recent years having resulted in some folks standards plummeting.
Pretty sure we were jumping for joy in the 1st game of the season at the same venue scoring a last minute goal, so aye, we would have been, and you are kidding yourself on.
 

Danger Zone

Just the tip...
Pretty sure we were jumping for joy in the 1st game of the season at the same venue scoring a last minute goal, so aye, we would have been, and you are kidding yourself on.
Yeah we hadn’t just allowed them to open up a 7 point gap off the back of a string or absolutely turgid performances when we won there at the start of the season.

But yeah I’m kidding myself. Some amount of Walter Mittys here.
 

douzpwa

Well-Known Member
There is no foul, Beaton’s view is blocked and he guesses based on the Kilmarnock player throwing himself.

The entire narrative today changes in that one moment, instead of being shitebags the players are praised for digging it out and showing character, we have been absolutely done by Beaton here.

I fully expect the usual pish about how we should dare mentions refs from the usual suspects, but we were fucking highlighting them after our win at Parkhead so kindly go and raffle yourselves.

Scandalous this wasn’t given:

What about the linesmen? All the match officials should be scrutinised!
 

Tagsbear

Well-Known Member
Yeah we hadn’t just allowed them to open up a 7 point gap off the back of a string or absolutely turgid performances when we won there at the start of the season.

But yeah I’m kidding myself. Some amount of Walter Mittys here.
Yes, you are. Did you just shake your head at all the Walter Mittys celebrating Hagis winner last week aye?
 

Danger Zone

Just the tip...
Yes, you are.
Of course, and you’re being honest with yourself, that’s why you’ve used the previous trip to rugby park as the basis for your argument and chosen to ignore the extremely different circumstances surrounding both games.

Nothing wrong with being glass half full, but sometimes folk take it to lengths where it spills over into the category of delusional.
 

the voice

Well-Known Member
What’s even worse is that the refs whistle goes a fraction before Alfie headers it, when the “contact” was just made and Beatons view is completely blocked.... he’s had his whistle in his mouth as the ball is going into the box and blows up unsighted when Morelos is connecting with an open goal.
 

Govanx

Cool Story Bro
These wee “incidents” can change the momentum of a game, for all the “we should be hammering teams like this” crowd. Griffiths intentional stamp on the Hamilton player, that should have seen the scum down to 10 men? Nothing to see here, move along please.
 

bluebellsareblu

Active Member
Dicker and Burke should have been off in the first half meaning the Alfie dives don’t happen and we win comfortably against 9 men

So your point is invalid
Wrong. You cannot state we would win comfortably. It simply isn’t true. It’s your opinion. Alfie sewing red stops him being on the park and being in that position. That is fact.
 
Top