If we are taking the concept of a 'Hall of Fame' being a serious thing with 'legends' filling it, then absolutely not.
For him to be added it would be purely because he is the captain of the team that wins 55.
That suggests the role of captain is important (something which some people on here usually argue it isn't).
If it is that important then he has been an abject failure as a captain so far
(not player).
On the pitch he has captained us during some of our most embarrassing defeats. Off the field things like his words in the programme last season or not facing the camera against Progres are pathetic.
As mentioned some people will say the role of captain is not important. In Scotland (and the UK) in my opinion it is. During our successes we have always had excellent leaders. Tav is clearly not a leader or anywhere near some of our legendary captains.
If we win the league this year it won't be because Tav is captain, it will be because we have the best team.
Pretty much echoes my thoughts on this with bottling the Cup final penalty jumping out too.