Poll: Best center back at the club

Who is the best center back at the club?

  • Katić

    Votes: 245 55.2%
  • Goldson

    Votes: 125 28.2%
  • Helander

    Votes: 70 15.8%
  • Edmundson

    Votes: 27 6.1%
  • McCrorie

    Votes: 5 1.1%

  • Total voters
    444

devilman

Well-Known Member
I don't think we've seen enough to judge Helander or Edmunson yet. However, I'd say out of Katic and Goldson, Katic is the better defender.

I'd like to see more of Helander and Edmunson as I do think they both could be better than Goldson either. Which is nice as Goldson isn't bloody bad either.
 

Recoba

Well-Known Member
Official Ticketer
Considering we have hardly seen 2 of them i don't see the point in this thread
 

Mitchell McCoist

Well-Known Member
Official Ticketer
Goldson is the best of the ones I’ve seen
Katic is the most in form of the ones I’ve seen
The other 2, I’ve no really seen
 

RainMan1972

Well-Known Member
I don't think we've seen enough to judge Helander or Edmunson yet. However, I'd say out of Katic and Goldson, Katic is the better defender.

I'd like to see more of Helander and Edmunson as I do think they both could be better than Goldson either. Which is nice as Goldson isn't bloody bad either.
That wasn`t the question tho
Okay, I'm just saying I don't know enough about Helander or Edmundson to claim they are better than Goldson and Katic. No idea how anyone can say they do, unless they have been consistently watching Chievo/Peterborough for the last year.

If we had signed a well known centre half that everyone knew about in terms of their quality then fair enough but we can't say that here.
 

Klaus

Well-Known Member
Goldson the better all round defender.

Katic stronger in the air and in the tackle but his positional sense if woeful at times.
 

HenningBerg

Well-Known Member
We are fortunate to have four excellent centre halves

To the ones who say we don’t need four , take a look at Man City just now

Helander is the only full international of the four and with serie A experience I think he will have a big part to play shortly
 

Danger Zone

Just the tip...
Goldson because he’s the manager’s first pick and managers never show favouritism or make mistakes. While we’re at it, that Helander money should have been put towards securing Worral on a permanent deal.

ps. We’re very lucky to have 4 very good centre backs
 

MearnsUnionist

Well-Known Member
Haven't seen enough of Helander or Edmundson to pass comment on them, but as much as I like Niko, I agree with our manager that Goldson is a superior all round central defender.
 

Polar bear

Well-Known Member
Very pleased with the four of them.I picked
Edmundson mainly because I see him becoming the best in the future.
 

Bob Belcher

Well-Known Member
Official Ticketer
Okay, I'm just saying I don't know enough about Helander or Edmundson to claim they are better than Goldson and Katic. No idea how anyone can say they do, unless they have been consistently watching Chievo/Peterborough for the last year.

If we had signed a well known centre half that everyone knew about in terms of their quality then fair enough but we can't say that here.
Chievo? Peterborough?
 

Polar bear

Well-Known Member
Mate the majority of your posts absolutely baffle me! Is Halliday still your pick for best left back at the club too?
[/
Out of the three left backs,yes it’s Andy for me.You have to understand people do have
difference of opinions.You really baffle me at times,but I do except your opinion.
Enjoy the win tonight ;)
 

The Lone Ranger

Well-Known Member
Why are people voting for Helander and Edmundson? We have seen them in around 3 games so far in total.

Surely we should be basing this off of what WE have seen of them playing for Rangers.
You would think so bit people were sayong he was a guaranteed starter based on the same information they hold now
 

Big Buff

Well-Known Member
Goldson is the best overall centre-back at the Club, capable of consistently putting in good-to-excellent performances in a number of defensive schemes and roles.

Katic is the best siege defender, and is aerially dominant. He is invaluable in games where we do not dominate the ball and the territory.

Helander and Edmundson, it's too early to say. Though both impressed me with their distribution, and Helander likes to step out of defence.
 

Gene_Okerlund

Well-Known Member
It's a crazy poll as 2 of them have barely kicked a ball.

From what i've seen of Edmundson, I really like the look of the boy.

Wins every header, So calm and composed, Pings a ball about Left and Right as if he's a seasoned pro. Perfect in the tackle.
 
Top