He should.Mcglynn will get it I think
It's not going to be Clement.
I love the guy, but regardless of the bin fire he inherited, he is currently sitting 2nd with the team who, at the start of the season, the football writers expected to finish 2nd. That is how the writers will spin it.
An old firm manager should only get it if they've already won the league cup, miles ahead in the league and in the final of the Scottish Cup.
That's why they're doing it just now so they don't need to give it to ClementAgain - timing? Why don’t they wait till the end of the season to vote?
If Clement were to pull off the miracle of the treble from what he inherited there would be no discussion.
Otherwise it’s McGlynn for me.
At this stage there isn't an outstanding candidate from that list.
If he wins the league then he fully deserves MOTY, if the filth win the title, it doesn't matter how many points better off than Celtic he was since he took over.Tbf, Clement, in his tenure, is 4 points clear of Celtic with one cup in the bag and another final.
It's Beales start that's done us in.
They do it the same time every yearThat's why they're doing it just now so they don't need to give it to Clement
If it’s all a conspiracy then why haven’t they included Rodgers?That's why they're doing it just now so they don't need to give it to Clement
Between him and McGlynn imo.if Clement had already secured the title, it would be him.
mcinnes has to win that though, he has done some job turning Killie around.
Up until a few weeks ago maybe.Only one winner there, not even being biased
Aye, McGlynn.Only one winner there, not even being biased
Thats the issue with the awards early doors mate, either could take their team up to the Prem and would be more than worth the shortlist at least.Surprised Ian Murray and Rhys McCabe haven't made the shortlist
Thought McCabe might have got a mentionSurprised Ian Murray and Rhys McCabe haven't made the shortlist
Aye.John McglynnOnly one winner there, not even being biased
Already won a cup,At this stage there isn't an outstanding candidate from that list.
Earlier than that, Jock Wallace won a treble, humping Manager of the Year Billy McNeill’s Aberdeen in the process.This daft charade should have been binned forever after Walter was snubbed.
Its now just an annual embarrassment.
Clement should not be on the list. I like our manager and rate him and he has done a decent job but (a) he is not deserving of a manager of the year award; and (b) he has not been here a full season. IMO he should not be a nominee.
Winning a league cup and last 16 isn't enough to warrant manager of the year.Already won a cup,
In another cup final,
Last 16 in Europe,
Chance of winning the league,
Yep there's no outstanding candidate right enough!!
Who else on that list has achieved more?Winning a league cup and last 16 isn't enough to warrant manager of the year.
If he wins the league definitely.
If he wins the league then he fully deserves MOTY, if the filth win the title, it doesn't matter how many points better off than Celtic he was since he took over.
You could make a point about a catastrophic slump which he had overseen which will count against him.
No one, doesn't mean that Clement deserves to win it though.Who else on that list has achieved more?
Not really, if it was based on trophies won it would be an OF manager every year. It's a far greater achievement to do what McInnes has done this season on a shoestring budget and having been shite last season than it is to spend millions and win everything.McInnes looks favourite for that.
Obviously hope it doesn't happen, but it will look a bit daft if they win the double and their manager isn't in the top 4.
They’ve been there for something like 5 seasons and he’s taken them up unbeaten, finishing on 90 points. It’s a hell of an achievement.McGlynn deserves huge credit winning league 1 with Falkirk. Who doesn't love a huge underdog story?
Why?McInnes will get it. And I think the nominations are a piss take.
I didn't say if they won the double, their manager should win it.Not really, if it was based on trophies won it would be an OF manager every year. It's a far greater achievement to do what McInnes has done this season on a shoestring budget and having been shite last season than it is to spend millions and win everything.
Winning a league cup and last 16 isn't enough to warrant manager of the year.
If he wins the league definitely.
Be successful domestically I would imagine?Well, if they keep telling us its what you do in Europe and not what you do in Scotland, then what is the criteria to win MOTY then. ?