HamiltonBear
Well-Known Member
Not a go at you but more than a few people have moved from "not good enough" to the above opinion.Never been about ability for me. He won’t stay fit unfortunately.
Not a go at you but more than a few people have moved from "not good enough" to the above opinion.Never been about ability for me. He won’t stay fit unfortunately.
Keeps the ball, knows when to lamp it, good to very good passing, breaks the lines.
Not sure why Europe would frighten him.
That's the same for everyone though, isn't it? He can only play against what's in front of him.I don’t think it’ll frighten him but I’m not sure he’s good enough for that yet.
He’s up against a far better standard of player than Curtis Main.
We always use the quality of the league to downplay the performances by any youth players or players signed from smaller clubs in this league... il bet you dont say aye well Tillman/Hagi/Morelos/Cantwell scored but it was only against the shite up here so it means very little.I don’t think it’ll frighten him but I’m not sure he’s good enough for that yet.
He’s up against a far better standard of player than Curtis Main.
Well I never said he wasn’t anyway.Not a go at you but more than a few people have moved from "not good enough" to the above opinion.
I had my doubts on ability. I felt he was doing brilliantly for Hearts when he was fit but I still wasn't convinced.Not a go at you but more than a few people have moved from "not good enough" to the above opinion.
And I was one of them looks like I will be eating a bit of the old humble pie , big enough to admit I was wrong .Quite a few on follow follow saying he was a Hearts level CB not so long ago
Assume he’s played European / International matches against players superior to CurtisI don’t think it’ll frighten him but I’m not sure he’s good enough for that yet.
He’s up against a far better standard of player than Curtis Main.
Quite a few on follow follow saying he was a Hearts level CB not so long ago
That's why I said not a go at you, BWell I never said he wasn’t anyway.
For me it feels like when Jack gets a run and people get carried away. It’s been an injury-plagued season, exactly as we feared. Hopefully his and our luck changes next season.thankfully we are
I am not getting carried away the real test is when we are playing 3 games a week on a regular basis, I was just trying to point out that I don't think anyone questioned his abilityFor me it feels like when Jack gets a run and people get carried away. It’s been an injury-plagued season, exactly as we feared. Hopefully his and our luck changes next season.
I know you aren’t, and I agree with your point. Though a few were ready to send him back to Hearts after we drew to Livingston on the first dayI am not getting carried away the real test is when we are playing 3 games a week on a regular basis, I was just trying to point out that I don't think anyone questioned his ability
he was someone I personally was never going to pin my hopes on of being a regular, I think when he got injured it was a case of well this was inevitable as I have said in another thread hopefully he has got all his injuries sorted as a fit Souttar looks a real assetI know you aren’t, and I agree with your point. Though a few were ready to send him back to Hearts after we drew to Livingston on the first day
To be fair, some do deserve this rammed up them.These weekly Souttar posts...
That can't be relied upon so if you build a squad where he's one of your starting XI it's basically planning to play with a worse player than him as your cb in every important game.Outstanding again. Won everything in the air, great positional sense and willing to stride forward with the ball. His range of passing is also very good. If he can stay fit, he should be a fixture in the team.
The DandyWasn't he a character in oor wullie or something?
Nope - I am talking bollocks _ your right it was Oor Wullie - Your Wullie - Abodys WullieThe Dandy
Still keeping my powder dry well dryish. He needs to stay fit, however when he made that mistake people on here tagged and dug me out and had a good laugh but I won't tag them back....yet.To be fair, some do deserve this rammed up them.
Too many wrote the lad off because of an error against Livingston.
He is certainly on the road to making his critics look very silly.
I think he means he said it all along.If you don't like it......
He reminds me of Craig Moore the way he defends quite aggressive and will put his body on the line.
Far better on the ball than Moore and the way he steps out with the ball thro the lines is something we've not really seen from our Centre backs.
Great passer as well just hope his injury woes are behind him as hes got the right ingredients to be a 1st pick.
I’d say a fully fit Souttar is a better footballer than GoldsonOutstanding again. Won everything in the air, great positional sense and willing to stride forward with the ball. His range of passing is also very good. If he can stay fit, he should be a fixture in the team.
Just posted the same thing at the same timeI’d say a fully fit Souttar is a better footballer than Goldson
Probably get abuse for this but at their best I think he is better than Goldson.
Much better on the ball than Goldson as in bringing the ball out and wins absolutely everything in the air.
He can actually intercept a cross or cut back aswell which is a good change in our defence.
He reminds me a little bit more of Bougherra.
Strong, aggressive and in the way he bursts forward with the ball from the backline.
Ha ha…. If he wasn’t Scottish I bet he’d get a lot more praise then he actually does on hereJust posted the same thing at the same time
He is a breath of fresh air in a defence that's been soft as shite all season.
If Goldson can perform in Europe, Souttar will have no problems.I don’t think it’ll frighten him but I’m not sure he’s good enough for that yet.
He’s up against a far better standard of player than Curtis Main.
If Goldson can perform in Europe, Souttar will have no problems.
Not for me. Souttar will prove to be a better defender than Goldson IMO.Goldson is a better player than Souttar