W. Foderingham - decent keeper, makes some good saves and some awful howlers, we could do better.
J. Alnwick - looked okay when I've seen him play, not seen enough.
L. Kelly - haven't seen much of him.
F. Cardoso - has looked average at best, maybe an extended run in the team would help him, jury very much out.
B. Alves - overrated and injury prone
D. Wilson - had been playing fairly well until the last couple of games, but generally shouldn't be considered anything more than a squad player.
D. Bates - one of the worst footballers I have seen play for us, makes Salim Kerkar look like Zidane, has some decent defensive attributes but simply not good enough.
R. McCrorie - probably his worst performance so far yesterday, but his quality is there for all to see.
L. Wallace - decent player, no more than that, his frequent injuries is a worry though.
D. John - awful defensively, seems okay going forward, very slight and too easily muscled off the ball.
J. Tavernier - Absolutely fantastic going forward, partial to lapses defensively but geys way more criticism than he deserves. Our best option at right back by quite some distance and would set us back a hefty transfer fee to replace him with a player of similar ability.
L. Hodson - awful, just awful.
G. Dorrans - has been a disappointment, but my expectations were so high for him it was probably unrealistic, will hopefully be a good player for us.
C. Peña - would like to see more of him, looks like he has never seen a football at times but has popped up with some important goals and did seem to improve in his last few games.
J. Barjonas - has looked decent, nothing special though, don't think he will ever be more than a squad player but will be happy to be proved wrong.
J. Rossiter - who?
Dálcio - from what I have seen he doesn't look good enough.
Ryan Jack - one of our best performers so far this season, possibly a bit of a discipline issue but had been unlucky in that regard also.
J. Holt - has surprised me a little this season been pretty good recently, but had a poor game yesterday. Decent squad player.
N. Kranjcar - past his best about 4 year ago.
J. Windass - probably our best creative threat, very underrated by alot of our support, can be frustrating the way he drifts in and out of games but gets more criticism than he deserves.
D. Candeias - can be anonymous for long periods but his final ball is superb, has definitely improved us.
A. Nemane - see dalcio.
E. Herrera - has looked average at best from what I have seen, hasn't really had enough game time though.
A. Morelos - had a fantastic start to the season, but struggled a bit for form since, was poor yesterday, had two chances put on a plate for him. Has been a fantastic signing though.
K. Miller - well past his best, shouldn't be near our starting 11 again.
R. Hardie - has an impressive record at youth level, hasn't shown much for the first team, would like to see him get a chance though.
Certainly need to improve right across the pitch, goalkeeper, centre back, left back left midfield, striker are areas we particularly need to strengthen in.
J. Alnwick - looked okay when I've seen him play, not seen enough.
L. Kelly - haven't seen much of him.
F. Cardoso - has looked average at best, maybe an extended run in the team would help him, jury very much out.
B. Alves - overrated and injury prone
D. Wilson - had been playing fairly well until the last couple of games, but generally shouldn't be considered anything more than a squad player.
D. Bates - one of the worst footballers I have seen play for us, makes Salim Kerkar look like Zidane, has some decent defensive attributes but simply not good enough.
R. McCrorie - probably his worst performance so far yesterday, but his quality is there for all to see.
L. Wallace - decent player, no more than that, his frequent injuries is a worry though.
D. John - awful defensively, seems okay going forward, very slight and too easily muscled off the ball.
J. Tavernier - Absolutely fantastic going forward, partial to lapses defensively but geys way more criticism than he deserves. Our best option at right back by quite some distance and would set us back a hefty transfer fee to replace him with a player of similar ability.
L. Hodson - awful, just awful.
G. Dorrans - has been a disappointment, but my expectations were so high for him it was probably unrealistic, will hopefully be a good player for us.
C. Peña - would like to see more of him, looks like he has never seen a football at times but has popped up with some important goals and did seem to improve in his last few games.
J. Barjonas - has looked decent, nothing special though, don't think he will ever be more than a squad player but will be happy to be proved wrong.
J. Rossiter - who?
Dálcio - from what I have seen he doesn't look good enough.
Ryan Jack - one of our best performers so far this season, possibly a bit of a discipline issue but had been unlucky in that regard also.
J. Holt - has surprised me a little this season been pretty good recently, but had a poor game yesterday. Decent squad player.
N. Kranjcar - past his best about 4 year ago.
J. Windass - probably our best creative threat, very underrated by alot of our support, can be frustrating the way he drifts in and out of games but gets more criticism than he deserves.
D. Candeias - can be anonymous for long periods but his final ball is superb, has definitely improved us.
A. Nemane - see dalcio.
E. Herrera - has looked average at best from what I have seen, hasn't really had enough game time though.
A. Morelos - had a fantastic start to the season, but struggled a bit for form since, was poor yesterday, had two chances put on a plate for him. Has been a fantastic signing though.
K. Miller - well past his best, shouldn't be near our starting 11 again.
R. Hardie - has an impressive record at youth level, hasn't shown much for the first team, would like to see him get a chance though.
Certainly need to improve right across the pitch, goalkeeper, centre back, left back left midfield, striker are areas we particularly need to strengthen in.
Last edited: