Timmy delusions - best player in Scotland

[gordy73]

Talking to timmy, giving him a few truths and he stated Rogic, on his day was the best player in Scotland by a country mile. I had told him that Rogic looked fine against Sean Goss and the likes and that was his response. He's a Rogic fan boy. So who do we think, on their day who is the best player in Scotland?

 

[km_2083]

Kent end of discussion

 

[Sutton_Blows_goats]

Fredo for me.

 

[AndyWebsterLoyal]

I went with Alfie, but easily could be Kent or Roofe as well.

 

[The Royal Standard]

On their day Kent walks it

 

[Modfella]

Kent and to think we baulked at £7.5Million when it was first mentioned.
Would only sell now for +£25Million.

 

[Main Stand]

You could throw in any one from our strongest 11 & you could make a solid case for any of them.

I voted Alfie, but would have voted for Kent, Aribo, Tav & Jack if I could have.

 

[Russ H]

Was going to click on Shane Duffy but could not see that option - What a signing he has been for us!

 

[Its-Sebo]

‘On their day’ is a bit of a flawed argument because in that case it’s Morelos by a mile, even against the likes of Kent. But he’s not been ‘on his day’ for a while despite being pretty good recently.

 

[China Bear]

Morelos, he will come good again, that I am certain

 

[Loud and proud]

Voted Davis.
What he brings to the team is unmatched in the league.

 

[The Hooded Claw]

Kent for mee too but Morelos, Roofe, Goldson not far behind with Kamara getting there with consistency

Forgot about Barisic, ffs we do have a good team

 

[Monster]

Roofe will be in time.

 

[The Pontiac Bandit]

This season...it's Tav.

Sorry but every other answer is wrong.

 

[DadoDrinksMilk]

On current form I had to go for Glen Kamara.

He has been outstanding of late.

 

[Grigo Yossarian]

Morelos for me based upon the question, but based upon who HAS REPEATEDLY been on their game this season Tavernier wins hands down for me.

If the season stopped today James Tavernier would win the POTY, even in this country.

 

[gordy73]

Was going to click on Shane Duffy but could not see that option - What a signing he has been for us!

I missed a trick there

 

[UpStepsTheHammer]

Out of all the options Kent and Morelos are the two where you see them on form and think %^*& me he is unplayable

 

[Graemeh89]

Kamara for me , wouldn’t look out of place in any midfield , he strolls through games and is getting better and better.

Most important current player for us is Tav. His form and the fact we don’t have much backup in that position makes him crucial.

 

[Bigmo1872]

Kamara for me he stroll through games

 

[Clay Davis]

Aribo should be on that list imo. Maybe not the best player in the league but I’d have him in the top 5.

 

[sregnar]

If every player is playing at the top of the game, it’s Eduoard isn’t it?

Thankfully he’s miles off it and totally not arsed by the looks of it.

 

[a_weir]

Right which bellend voted for French Eddie?

 

[Realger34]

My favourite Rangers player Kent!

 

[Southside_shug]

Kamara has been exceptional, closely followed by Davis

No one comes close to these two

 

[sregnar]

Right which bellend voted for French Eddie?

Me. Least I never called him “french Eddie” though

 

[Grigo Yossarian]

Joe Aribo wasn’t included in the options, and has been extremely unlucky with injuries & illness after a brilliant pre season.

To me he has a skill set that no other midfielder in this country can match, and if he gets fit & plays as he can, he can still win POTY in my
Opinion.

 

[Worthy_Candidate]

Kent or Aribo have the most natural ability... perhaps neither is the most effective due to obvious consistency levels which will improve.

Right now, the most effective player in Scotland right now is our very own Glen Kamara.

 

[gordy73]

Aribo should be on that list imo. Maybe not the best player in the league but I’d have him in the top 5.

Aribo has the potential but he's been stop start this season with injures. I think if he can get a settled run then there's no ceiling for him, or a very high one at least

 

[Frank Burnside]

Roofe for me. I think more people will agree at the end of the season.

 

[Morty Smith]

Might have picked Kamara if he was an option, i genuinely believe he could play at any level and not look out of place.

 

[chucknorris]

This season...it's Tav.

Sorry but every other answer is wrong.

Has to be this season

 

[Marvellous Marvin]

Kent for me. On his game miles ahead of any other player in his position.

 

[davydumper]

Who voted for Eddie “Odd Sock”

 

[gordy73]

Joe Aribo wasn’t included in the options, and has been extremely unlucky with injuries & illness after a brilliant pre season.

To me he has a skill set that no other midfielder in this country can match, and if he gets fit & plays as he can, he can still win POTY in my
Opinion.

It the injuries this season, been to stop start but if he gets a run and is settled there is no ceiling for him

 

[DKS137]

Tavernier. He could be a Brazilian!

 

[Gerrard 55]

Voted Kent. If Morelos got back to start of last seasons form it’s him by a mile

 

[Gary Mitchell]

What no Duffy.

 

[St Andrews Bear]

On current form I had to go for Glen Kamara.

He has been outstanding of late.

I went to click Kamara, then paused and thought Tav who’s been outstanding, then hesitated again and thought when Alfie is on fire he is unplayable so still haven’t decided.
What I do know is none of their squad even comes close

 

[Grigo Yossarian]

If every player is playing at the top of the game, it’s Eduoard isn’t it?

Thankfully he’s miles off it and totally not arsed by the looks of it.

People on FF criticise Alfie a fair bit, but Edouard is way over rated when you see him against good teams, ie us & Europe.

Additionally he can play games & just be totally invisible & doesn’t have Alfie’s spirit in forcing himself into matches.

Yes, great goal last week v Sparta, but pretty anonymous otherwise & totally anonymous when I saw Copenhagen scud them too.

 

[Carnwadric-bluenose]

Went with Kent as he's genuinely a player that can get you off your seat when on form .

 

[Mr Wilton]

It’s Kent, but the more we see of Roofe the more it’s going to be him!

 

[LiborSionko14]

For us it’s got to be Morelos or Kent but if you take the blue tinted specs off Edouard will give them a run for his money when he’s on his game.

 

[the_ref]

had to go for Morelos, on his day, unplayable, but was struggling to decide between him or Kent. Or Eduoard, for a laugh.

 

[Grigo Yossarian]

It the injuries this season, been to stop start but if he gets a run and is settled there is no ceiling for him

Agree Gordy.

He has a dimension our other midfielders don’t have in terms of ability to hurt teams with goals & assists mate.

 

[giogaddi]

Talking to timmy, giving him a few truths and he stated Rogic, on his day was the best player in Scotland by a country mile. I had told him that Rogic looked fine against Sean Goss and the likes and that was his response. He's a Rogic fan boy. So who do we think, on their day who is the best player in Scotland?

Rogic

Guy sounds like an absolute maniac.

 

[Jelle1880]

Honestly depends on the position.

But I genuinely think we have the best squad in the country and in each position the best player in the league.

Goal: McGregor
Defence: Tav
Midfield: Kent
Attack: Morelos on his day, but Defoe has to be up there.

 

[gordy73]

Might have picked Kamara if he was an option, i genuinely believe he could play at any level and not look out of place.

He is

 

[a_weir]

Me. Least I never called him “french Eddie” though

lol

 

[gordy73]

Agree Gordy.

He has a dimension our other midfielders don’t have in terms of ability to hurt teams with goals & assists mate.

And they big long legs to steal the ball or keep it away from multiple others