Tugayloyal
Active Member
Just was the manks on sportscene, not a chance that was hand ball new rules or not total gift!!!
Hibs had a much better claim in the first half and it didn't merit a mention from the pundits in the discussion after the game.Just was the manks on sportscene, not a chance that was hand ball new rules or not total gift!!!
Can only give a foul if the ball is in play - I’ve not seen the incident you are talking about though.The build-up to their equaliser was a farce as well.
Madden blows his whistle and stops the game for a foul on the Hibs player, but rather than give Hibs a free kick he allows the mentally challengeds to retake theirs and they score from it.
Aye but when the kick is re-taken Duffy commits exactly the same offence when the ball is in play.Its a retake because the ball wasnt in play when he pulled up duffy.always been the rule.
Its a retake because the ball wasnt in play when he pulled up duffy.always been the rule.
Can only give a foul if the ball is in play - I’ve not seen the incident you are talking about though.
The Celtic penalty is a penalty, as is the hibs one
I watched the highlights on the BBC and it never showed a replay of the handball.Just watching it. Ours was “soft”, but theirs was never a penalty
And the same foul takes place againThe build-up to their equaliser was a farce as well.
Madden blows his whistle and stops the game for a foul on the Hibs player, but rather than give Hibs a free kick he allows the mentally challengeds to retake theirs and they score from it.
Just was the manks on sportscene, not a chance that was hand ball new rules or not total gift!!!
He said going by both teams current form. Which is true. Just need to make sure we keep current firm to league is over.Stewart also said celtic wouldnt catch us
Unsurprising given the officials know ‘what is at stake this season.’Hibs had a much better claim in the first half and it didn't merit a mention from the pundits in the discussion after the game.
W.A.T.P.
What about the one that hits Ajer on the hand twice?Can only give a foul if the ball is in play - I’ve not seen the incident you are talking about though.
The Celtic penalty is a penalty, as is the hibs one
Really? Haven’t seen it, although entirely unsurprised.What about the one that hits Ajer on the hand twice?
Yeah mate he is slighting on the dec and ball hits his supporting arm (out with his silhouette), goes back to the Hibs player and then looks to hit the same arm again. All with in a split second.Really? Haven’t seen it, although entirely unsurprised.
Don’t believe you. Has Michael Stewart got a “double”. Roofe was a penalty all day and unfortunately so was there’s. Handball Law needs looked at.Both Foster and Stewart said it was never a penalty, plus they said our's was a stonewaller.
Honestly!!!!
compare it to this one not given by Mr Walsh.
That’s one he owes us next game.
compare it to this one not given by Mr Walsh.
M8 he should be calling it a day or going to spec savers. Thats cheating plain and simple. No excuses.
Just watching it. Ours was “soft”, but theirs was never a penalty
Nick Walsh in my opinion is a good referee. He will know he got the penalty call wrong today. But agree needs to get the “Big calls right”. Don’t believe he’s a cheat. But agree others will have a difference of opinion on FF. Sometimes you are too close to the incident. If I was to show you incident from four different angles bet you would not have same outcome on all four angles.
Have you seen the Jason Holt tackle from yesterday. Now that’s a leg breaker and no card issued.
Referees are human and make mistakes like players.
a player of both teams offends , the kick is retaken unless a player commits a more serious offence
Nick Walsh in my opinion is a good referee. He will know he got the penalty call wrong today. But agree needs to get the “Big calls right”. Don’t believe he’s a cheat. But agree others will have a difference of opinion on FF. Sometimes you are too close to the incident. If I was to show you incident from four different angles bet you would not have same outcome on all four angles.
Have you seen the Jason Holt tackle from yesterday. Now that’s a leg breaker and no card issued.
Referees are human and make mistakes like players.
%^*& me!compare it to this one not given by Mr Walsh.
sorry m8 cant buy that. He was looking at it from a head on view and to not give is not a mistake. As others have said if it was not pivotal its given. He knew what he was doing aka cheating
Agree it was not pivotal today but other games it has been - Hibs. It evens itself out over the course of the season. As I’ve said - we are owed a few.
The trouble I have with your last sentence is that I struggle to remember the mistakes they are making that benefit us.
Non this season I agree. But we will return at end of season and we will have had decisions go in our favour.
m8 clancy was 4th official today. Will he now ref the away game?
Non this season I agree. But we will return at end of season and we will have had decisions go in our favour.