RandyMac
Well-Known Member
Surely to goodness you’re no putting they comparisons on a par?Laudrup or Capucho?
Surely to goodness you’re no putting they comparisons on a par?Laudrup or Capucho?
That’s is exactly my thoughtsThe longer BM has been away, the better he’ll become on FF
Ignore the facts that he would give us 1 good game in 6/7, was dropped by MW and then dropped by Pedro.
Ignore that when the going got tough, he’d be hiding.
Glad he’s gone. Not overly keen on Windass either mind you.
Noticed BM was benched last week by Warburton
One wants to stay, the other wanted away.
I wonder what Windass stats this season are, compared to McKay in the whole of last season?
Burke was not a bad player.Dont think so, just another Chris Burke imo.
Barrie McKay will be the biggest mistake we've ever made
Burke was not a bad player.
He was a far better and significantly more consistent player than McKay thats for sure. Also far better than Josh Windass.
McKay has great natural ability and his control is sublime at times but he was posted missing far too often for me. He rarely turned up ffs in the SPL.
As for McKay being the biggest mistake we ever made - what a complete lot of nonsense.
Neither of them would have get anywhere near a proper Rangers team.
Neither is McKay, to be honest.Windass is not a winger - he's been played out of position.
Unfortunately this.Forest will be the biggest mistake he'll make.
At the start of the season it looked a very foolish move to offload McKay and keep Windass however McKay has gone off the boil at Forest as Windass has started to find the net for us.
Both are similar players in that they are capable of some very good moments but at the same time are perceived to lack any dig and tend to blow hot and cold. This is what annoys fans the most imo.
Windass should never be played out wide again. He’s a striker for me now or tucked in behind with a free role.
This .McKay by a country mile.
Barrie McKay will be the biggest mistake we've ever made
Ever heard of Jim Forrest ?Barrie McKay will be the biggest mistake we've ever made
Wish it was both. Freezing out Barrie then letting him go for £500k was mental.
Barrie on the left with Windass behind the striker would be good.
If forced to pick between them I would say Windass currently in the form he is in. Barrie will likely be the better player in 5 years or so though.
Which one? Wilson, Keppel or BettyWindass is starting to affect matches regularly.
McKay is a sand dancer. Heart of a mouse.
Has he went off the boil? How's he been playing?
I've spoken to a few Forrest fans who love him. Haven't heard a bad word about him yet and they can't believe that they got a player of his ability so cheap.
That pretty much sums it up.Neither are out and out left wingers. McKay can play on right or as 10. Windass simply isn't a left winger.